Commentary: Draft opinion striking down Roe brings 'fire to this fight once again'

Kate Michelman, The Baltimore Sun on

Published in Op Eds

The now infamous Supreme Court draft opinion by Justice Samuel Alito, repealing Roe v. Wade, is not just a shameful ransacking of a 50-year-old precedent, it is an epic assault on the fundamental right of women to participate as equals in American society.

Roe is not just about the medical procedure of abortion and protecting women’s health and lives, it is also about women’s autonomy, dignity and status as citizens. A woman’s choice whether or not to bear a child lies at the very core of her being, and when politicians seize control of that choice, she is relegated to second class citizenship and deemed incapable of making her own life decisions.

Justice Alito’s opinion railroads women back to the 1960s, when we endured the powerlessness and humiliation of having male politicians determine our childbearing choices. I lived through those times, and will fight like hell against those who would force my daughters and granddaughter to surrender their rights.

In 1969, my husband had abruptly left my three young daughters and me, stranding us without financial support. Our family was in crises, and when I found out a few weeks later that I was pregnant, I knew it was impossible to give a new baby what it deserved while also giving my daughters what they needed. So, I made the decision to have an abortion.

The stigma attached to abortion left me in a state of pervasive aloneness and in total silence, with no one I could turn to in this moment of personal crisis. And, because state law radically restricted access to the procedure, that decision had humiliating consequences.

One option was to have an illegal abortion, which involved significant risks that could result in death or serious, long-term medical repercussions, which made me terrified for daughters’ well-being. The only other option was to apply for a hospital procedure, which required written permission both from the man who had abandoned me and my daughters, and approval from an all-male hospital board.

The board’s interrogation in a cold, brightly lit hospital conference room was the most humiliating experience of my life. I was asked whether I was capable of dressing my children in the mornings and even whether I had been satisfying my husband sexually.

That experience sparked a lifetime of activism that eventually took me to the front ranks of the pro-choice movement. Many Republicans were among us. But not anymore — because a party of moderation and individual liberty has today mutated into a party of intolerance and cruelty, intent on waging a war on a myriad of women’s rights and liberties achieved over the past 50 years. The fact that Republican legislation now excludes exceptions for rape, incest and the life of the woman is evidence of the extremism and misogyny that embodies their contempt for women’s autonomy and freedom.


Today, I am once again unsure of the future women face as the value of women’s lives are degraded and threatened — and I am utterly and deeply convinced that something about our country must fundamentally change.

The coming months are crucial for resistance at many levels. We must seize every opportunity: from national political protest, to local community activism, to civil disobedience. For certain, electing and re-electing pro-choice legislators in the critical upcoming mid-term elections must be a top priority. I made this fight my life’s work five decades ago, and by God, I will bring that fire to this fight once again. We must ensure the hands of time are not turned back on women.



Kate Michelman is president emeritus of NARAL Pro-Choice America and author of “With Liberty & Justice for All: A Life Spent Protecting the Right to Choose.”


©2022 The Baltimore Sun. Visit at baltimoresun.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


blog comments powered by Disqus


Lee Judge Peter Kuper RJ Matson Mike Peters Walt Handelsman Adam Zyglis