COUNTERPOINT: The Supreme Court has brought the need for expansion upon itself
Published in Op Eds
Americans’ faith in the Supreme Court has never been lower. In September, only 34 percent approved of how the high court was doing its job, down from 62% in 2001. The collapse in confidence dismays Chief Justice John Roberts, who has pushed back against critics’ claims that the court has been politicized and has lost its historical independence from Congress and the White House.
Reasons for the fall in public faith range from some justices’ conflicts of interest and financial gains from outside activities to Republican senators’ brazen hypocrisy in handling different presidents’ Supreme Court nominations. A key moment was the court’s June 22, 2022, overturning of Roe v. Wade, which contradicted assurances several justices had made in their confirmation hearings that they would protect the constitutional right to obtain an abortion.
But the biggest reason for declining public support is that the justices’ deliberations have become less transparent. While other countries have expanded their highest courts to manage increased caseloads, our Supreme Court has taken a more troubling approach.
Employing what has become known as the shadow docket, the court releases unsigned opinions, with no comment, at times on major cases. The rulings are made without oral argument and with little or no written briefing, preventing Americans from understanding the key issues at play and the justices’ reasoning.
University of Pennsylvania law professor Kate Shaw said the increased number of such rulings is undermining the work of federal district and appellate courts — to the point that some irritated lower-court judges, who are not told why their detailed briefs were repudiated, have ignored them.
In using the shadow docket, Shaw said, the Supreme Court has exhibited “manifest disrespect shading into contempt” for lower courts. That the number of these sparse decisions grew during President Donald Trump’s first term, fell under President Joe Biden, and is again expanding in Trump’s second term heightens the impression that the high court has become a political tool.
“Shadow docket grants have included orders permitting the (Trump) administration to remove individuals to third countries without complying with the Convention Against Torture, to expel transgender service members from the military, to permit roving ICE raids to stop citizens and non-citizens alike,” Shaw said. “The court did not offer one word of reasoning in any of those cases.”
Still worse, some of the most consequential rulings have been made by narrow 6-3 or even 5-4 margins.
Other countries have been more straightforward in responding to their high courts’ growing caseloads. Some have added judges, including Canada, the United Kingdom and India.
Legal scholars have argued that the United States should follow suit. A 36-member commission Biden set up to weigh Supreme Court reforms deadlocked on expansion, but two prominent members ended up favoring more justices after initially preferring term limits.
Nancy Gertner, a retired federal district judge, and Harvard constitutional law professor Lawrence Tribe were unsparing in their criticism of the current high court.
“Instead of serving as a guardrail against going over that (antidemocratic) cliff, our Supreme Court has become an all-too-willing accomplice in that disaster,” they wrote in the Washington Post.
While opponents of adding justices use the derogatory term “packing” to disparage it, Gertner and Tribe said Republican senators have used dishonest means of appointment.
When former President Barack Obama nominated Merrick Garland on March 16, 2016, after the death of Justice Anton Scalia, Senate Republicans killed the nomination by refusing to give him a hearing for almost eight months until Obama’s tenure ended. They said the appointment came too close to the November elections and voters should have a chance to weigh in on the high court’s direction.
That unscrupulous maneuver enabled Trump to nominate Neil Gorsuch on Jan. 31, 2017, just 11 days after he was inaugurated, who was quickly confirmed. Yet, when Trump nominated Amy Coney Barrett on Sept. 18, 2020, following Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s death, the Republican-controlled Senate confirmed her 27 days later — 19 days before the 2020 elections.
“Offsetting the way the court has been ‘packed’ in an antidemocratic direction with added appointments leaning the other way is the most significant clearly constitutional step that could be taken quickly,” Gertner and Tribe wrote.
Former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg, who ran for president in 2020 and is considering a 2028 campaign, proposes expanding the Supreme Court to 13 justices. That number matches the number of federal appellate courts.
Beyond partisan politics, the United States’ rise as the leading global power is the best argument for adding justices. The Constitution is silent on the high court’s size, and Congress has changed it seven times, most recently in 1869. Since then, the U.S. population has grown ninefold. The economy is 185 times larger, or 21 times per American.
During that period, Congress grew from 317 to 535 members. And the number of executive-agency employees has increased 40-fold.
The huge growth in every facet of American life has made the United States a much more litigious country, sparking many more complex legal issues. Asking just nine justices to decide them is unfair and illogical. The Supreme Court must be expanded.
_____
ABOUT THE WRITER
James Rosen is a former political reporter and Pentagon correspondent for McClatchy Newspapers. He received awards from the National Press Club, Military Reporters & Editors Association, and the Society of Professional Journalists, which in 2021 named him the top opinion columnist. He wrote this for InsideSources.com.
_____
©2026 Tribune Content Agency, LLC


















































Comments