Noah Feldman: It's not a crime for Congress to investigate the president
Published in Op Eds
A preview of the constitutional struggle that lies ahead arrived at the Capitol last week on White House letterhead. In a letter sent to Representative Robert Garcia, the California Democrat who will be chairing the House Oversight Committee next year, White House Counsel William Scharf warned that congressional oversight “may cross the line into blatant criminality.” Later, asked if the White House would comply with congressional subpoenas, he told Bloomberg News: “It depends,” adding that the president “would not be bullied.”
The suggestion of criminality, with its barely veiled threat of criminal prosecution, is constitutionally preposterous. The Speech and Debate Clause of the Constitution clearly protects members of Congress from any form of executive branch coercion, including criminal prosecution, for acts undertaken on the floor of Congress, which would include the decision to seek subpoenas and discuss whatever subject they wish, including presidential corruption.
It’s one of the clearest and best understood provisions of the Constitution, with origins in the English Bill of Rights of 1689. Its purpose is to preserve the separation of powers by protecting members of Congress from executive action.
The constitutional issues surrounding oversight subpoenas are more complicated. For 200 years, every time Congress subpoenaed the executive and there was some dispute between the two branches, a solution was reached by negotiation. That ended in President Donald Trump’s first term, when oversight committees issued subpoenas for Trump and his family members’ financial records going back more than a decade. Trump refused to comply on the grounds that the request went beyond Congress’s authority.
Despite the long tradition of staying out of disputes between Congress and the president, the Supreme Court agreed to hear the case in 2020. The decision that resulted, Trump v. Mazars, was the first time the court had weighed in on the constitutionality of a congressional subpoena.
In an opinion by Chief Justice John Roberts, the court held that Congress must have a “valid legislative purpose” in an oversight investigation to justify the subpoenas issued in its course. That means, in principle, that Congress must be able to say that there is some legislation it could undertake to remedy a problem being explored through its subpoena power.
Roberts reasoned that because Congress has the power to legislate but not the power to criminally prosecute, potential criminal prosecution was not a sufficient ground for a subpoena. (Congress’s subpoena authority would be different in the case of an impeachment inquiry, but in order to trigger that, Congress must designate a committee to engage in impeachment.)
Roberts laid out four factors to govern courts’ review of a congressional subpoena in case of presidential refusal. First, courts should assess the asserted purpose, cautiously, in order to avoid confrontations with the executive branch. Second, the courts should interpret the power as no broader than reasonably necessary, again, to avoid conflict where possible. Third, courts should look for Congress to provide “detailed and substantial evidence” for why the subpoena advances about legislative purpose. Finally, the courts should consider the burden imposed on the president by the subpoena, with an eye to the danger that Congress might be trying to use its subpoena power to gain some advantage in its institutional relationship with the executive.
The opinion was a modest victory for the executive. As written, all the factors seemed designed to limit congressional authority. In practice, however, in the lower courts, Congress was able to make the credible argument that it needed the information to consider potential legislation regarding presidential corruption. Ultimately, Trump did have to hand over the financial records, and he did so in 2022, after he was out of office.
A similar valid legislative purpose that underlay the previous investigations can certainly be stated by Congress if it subpoenas Trump and his family members and members of the executive branch on corruption charges. It is emphatically within Congress’s legislative purview to legislate against presidential corruption.
But that’s not the end of the story. One important effect of the Mazars decision is that Trump can refuse the congressional subpoenas, then force the issue to the courts. The courts will then have to consider the various arguments on both sides, thus delaying the investigations and running the clock in favor of the Trump administration. Even if the ultimate outcome is a Supreme Court decision upholding the subpoenas, the investigations will be thwarted in the meantime.
The White House counsel’s letter, then, is a blueprint for a concrete plan. Trump has every incentive to fight subpoenas and change the subject from corruption scandals. While he’s at it, Trump can breach constitutional norms and threaten members of Congress with criminal investigation. No court would consider the charges, but Congress can’t do anything about the threat other than impeach the president for making it. And without a fundamental change in political conditions, such a threat is likely to ring hollow to a president twice impeached and twice acquitted.
_____
This column reflects the personal views of the author and does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.
Noah Feldman is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. A professor of law at Harvard University, he is author, most recently, of “To Be a Jew Today: A New Guide to God, Israel, and the Jewish People."
_____
©2026 Bloomberg L.P. Visit bloomberg.com/opinion. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


















































Comments