Editorial: The new American Dream for many is an affordable lease. Smarter public policy can help

The Editorial Board, Chicago Tribune on Oct 6, 2026

Published in Op Eds

By clicking submit, I authorize Arcamax and its affiliates to: (1) use, sell, and share my information for marketing purposes, including cross-context behavioral advertising, as described in our Privacy Policy , (2) add to information that I provide with other information like interests inferred from web page views, or data lawfully obtained from data brokers, such as past purchase or location data, or publicly available data, (3) contact me or enable others to contact me by email or other means with offers for different types of goods and services, and (4) retain my information while I am engaging with marketing messages that I receive and for a reasonable amount of time thereafter. I understand I can opt out at any time through an email that I receive, or by clicking here

This page has long supported home ownership as a proven way to build wealth and security.

Alas, for an increasing share of the population, stretching to buy a home is a perilous financial move. Far from throwing money away, renting is looking better by the day. Public officials can help by avoiding poorly conceived new rules that would only make renting more expensive.

The tilt toward renting over buying comes down to simple math. The typical interest rate on 30-year mortgages is now over 7%. The average monthly payment on a new loan is going up, up, up. American consumers who couldn’t afford to buy a home when rates were in the fours will be hard-pressed to buy in the sevens today.

At the same time, home prices have continued to rise in many places, particularly the Chicago area. One of the main culprits is the shortage of homes. Plenty of builders who got burned in the 2008-09 financial crisis never made a strong comeback. Millions of homes were shelved that otherwise would have been built, had economic conditions been favorable.

The combination of higher rates and short supply discourages current homeowners from moving, especially those who are locked into mortgages at affordably low interest rates. That “lock-in effect” makes the inventory of homes even tighter, pushing prices higher still, a phenomenon that’s been particularly acute in the Chicago market.

Construction costs are soaring, too. Skilled labor is hard to come by. Plus, President Donald Trump’s tariffs and his war against Iran have jacked up the price of building materials like Canadian lumber as well as diesel fuel needed to deliver supplies and operate machinery.

It’s not as if demand for housing is down. But when renters run the numbers, most keep on renting.

Higher mortgage rates are the most conspicuous factor putting homes out of financial reach, but not the only one. Buying a home usually requires a big down payment and expensive closing costs. Renters typically need only a security deposit and the first month’s rent, so the up-front costs of renting are much lower.

Homeowners also need to keep up their homes. For most renters, landlords are responsible for all significant maintenance. So, if the refrigerator goes out, it’s not the tenant’s problem. Appliances, by the way, are among the products facing price increases partly attributable to tariffs.

Still, for many homeowners, building equity makes the expenses and risks worth it. Over time, most homes have appreciated dramatically. Across America, the average net worth of owners greatly exceeds the net worth of renters. No wonder homeownership remains central to the American Dream.

The so-called K-shaped economy, however, is remaking the calculus. The top of the “K” reflects the rising fortunes of high-income households, who are far more likely to enjoy the wealth-building benefits of owning a home. The bottom of the “K” reflects the struggles of lower- and middle-income households, many of whom are finding themselves priced out of home ownership.

Tax policy is making those fortunes diverge even more. Property taxes and interest on mortgages and home-equity loans are deductible up to certain caps, providing a huge (and treasured) tax break. Profits from the sale of homes get special treatment, too.

Renters don’t get the same tax breaks, and no one is talking about making rent payments deductible. Government policy should be helping renters more than it has.

The biggest help by far would be increasing the supply of rental units.

As Chicago Ald. Gilbert Villegas pointed out in a recent Chicago Tribune op-ed, Illinois is lagging badly behind other states in permits issued for new housing construction. The city has updated its rules to encourage “granny flats” and coach houses. But Chicago still needs better zoning and permitting to jump-start development, such as allowing multifamily buildings on smaller-sized lots.

Many Americans are going to be renting for the rest of their lives. They need as much choice as possible and they and their landlords need healthy competition.

_____