Dear Anna,

I’m 28 and have been with my girlfriend for about a year and a half. Things are really good between us overall, but we keep hitting a wall over one specific issue: I occasionally text with an ex from about four years ago. And I do mean occasionally. We’re talking maybe once or twice a month, maybe less than that. And the gist is: How’s work, did you see that movie, that kind of thing. We’re not close friends, we don’t hang out, and there’s absolutely zero romantic feeling on my end. But it really bothers my girlfriend. Her argument is that this ex wasn’t great to me when we dated — which is partially true, we had a rocky ending — and she doesn’t understand why I’d want to maintain any contact with someone who hurt me. She frames it as being protective of me, which I appreciate in theory, but in practice it feels like she’s making a decision about my relationships for me. I’m a grown-ass man who has processed that relationship and moved on, and I’m capable of deciding who I want to have casual contact with. I don’t think I’m doing anything wrong, but I also don’t want to keep upsetting her. Is she being reasonable or controlling or is it something else? — Considerations Of Meddling Exes Or No?

Dear COMEON,

This is one of those situations where both people have a point, and that’s exactly what makes it so frustrating to navigate.

Your girlfriend isn’t wrong that exes can be complicated, and it’s genuinely sweet that she wants to protect you from someone who hurt you. But you didn’t ask to be protected. You’re an adult who has processed that relationship, made peace with it, and decided on your own terms that occasional casual contact feels fine. If it truly distressed you to text with this ex, that would be one thing, but it doesn’t (at least from here).

That said, it’s entirely possible she’s experiencing her actions as purely altruistic. Plenty of loving people overstep because their anxiety convinces them they’re helping. Good intentions don’t automatically make a request reasonable, but they also don’t automatically make it controlling.

To make it even more complicated — both positions seem like relatively small asks.

Is giving up two casual text conversations a month with an ex an enormous sacrifice? Probably not.

Is asking your partner to stop texting an ex a couple of times a month an outrageous request? Also probably not.

But! As with most relationship issues, it’s not really about the texts. It’s about what’s underneath them.

To her, they may represent leaving a door ajar to someone who once hurt you — or a lingering connection she can’t quite make sense of. To you, they may represent your autonomy, your belief that people can move on without becoming enemies, or simply your right to decide which relationships from your past you carry into your present.

That’s the conversation I’d want you to have.

Not, “Who’s right?” But, “What does this relationship mean to each of us, and why does it matter so much?”

Let’s start with you. If your ex stopped texting tomorrow, what would you actually lose? And I don’t mean that as a trick question. I mean it because if you’re asking your current partner to live with something that bothers her, it’s worth understanding why it’s important to you. Is it that you value staying on good terms with people who were once significant? That you don’t like burning bridges? That these conversations are simply pleasant additions to your life? Or is there something else you’re getting from them — a sense of nostalgia, a connection to an earlier chapter of your life, the reassurance of knowing someone who once mattered still thinks of you? None of those motivations necessarily mean you’re doing anything wrong. But knowing your own answer will help you explain it — and it may even surprise you.

Then I’d get curious about your girlfriend’s side. Rather than asking, “Is this really about protecting me, or are you just jealous?” I’d ask, “What are you afraid will happen if I keep texting her?” Is she worried you’ll get hurt again? That your ex will manipulate you? That the flames will rekindle and she’ll get left in the dust? Or is it just that she doesn’t understand why someone who treated you poorly still has a place in your life? Those are very different fears, and they’ll lead to very different conversations.

One thing I also noticed: You say this bothers your girlfriend, but you don’t actually say what she’s asking for. Is she simply telling you she’s uncomfortable? Is she asking if you’d consider stopping? Or is she insisting that you cut your ex off? Those aren’t the same thing. Expressing discomfort is part of being in a relationship. Making requests is part of being in a relationship. Demanding that your partner end a relationship they value is a much bigger thing.

Every relationship involves deciding which accommodations are worth making for one another. We all adjust our lives around our partners’ needs and vulnerabilities to some extent. The question isn’t whether either of you should ever bend; it’s whether the request is proportional and whether the value of keeping this connection outweighs the cost it’s creating between you.

One last thing: The fact that this ex wasn’t great to you isn’t irrelevant. It’s one reason your girlfriend is reacting so strongly. But it’s not the only relevant fact. Another is that you’re the one who lived that relationship, processed it, and gets to decide what place — if any — that person occupies in your life now.

She doesn’t have to like that decision. But if this relationship is going to work, she does have to trust that you’re capable of making it. And if you’re asking for that trust, it’s fair for her to ask you why this particular connection is one you want to keep.

©2026 Tribune Content Agency, LLC.