Dear Anna,

I'm 23, and I've been with my girlfriend for about a year and a half. It’s my first real relationship and I love her, genuinely. She stuck by me through a rough stretch when I was dealing with some family stuff, and I don't take that for granted. Things aren't bad most of the time. We laugh together, we're comfortable, we care about each other. But we've had a few blowups that felt like near misses — like the relationship could've ended right there. The most recent one really shook me, and now I can't stop wondering if we're actually right for each other long term.

Here's the complicated part: a while back, I did something that broke her trust. She could have left. She didn't. She gave me another shot. So now, when I imagine wanting space or time apart, I feel like garbage — like I'm the one who gets to walk away scot-free after she was the one who forgave me. I don't think I want to end things permanently. I think I need time to figure out what I actually want. But she's basically my whole social life right now — I moved for a job and haven't built much of a friend group here, so losing her also means losing most of my day-to-day connection to people. I can't tell if I want to stay because I believe in us, or because I'm scared of being alone with myself. I keep picturing the conversation where I tell her I need space and how much it would hurt her, and I hate it. I'm scared I'll regret leaving. I'm also scared I'll regret staying just because I was too afraid to leave. — Torn And Tired

Dear TAT,

I want to name something first. The guilt you're describing isn't proof you should stay with her. It's proof you're a person with a conscience. Of course you feel bad! You're contemplating hurting someone you love.

In any case, I'm going to be more direct than you probably want me to be: I don’t think this relationship is serving you anymore, and you should end it. Not “take some space,” not a “temporary break,” but the whole kit and caboodle.

I think you know deep down that ending things is what you want to do. What you don't know is how to tolerate what comes afterward. Which makes sense. It’s scary! It hurts!

Breaking up is also harder when you still love the person. She supported you through a difficult time. You have fun together sometimes. You have history. Those things matter and they make these things more complex. (See above: RE your conscience.)

But in your letter, I don't hear someone asking, How do I repair this relationship?

I hear, How do I give myself permission to leave?

You keep circling the same questions: Do I actually want this? Am I staying because I'm afraid to be alone? Will I regret it? Am I leaving my whole social life, too? Am I allowed to walk away after she forgave me?

And underneath almost all of those questions is fear. Fear of uncertainty. Fear of loneliness. Fear of hurting her.

All understandable and admirable, of course, but fear is a terrible reason to stay with someone. I’m picturing the Hallmark card now: I choose you, I guess, because making new friends is hard.

And I hate to break this to you, but there isn't a magic solution to the hurting-her part. It’s gonna hurt — for both of you. It’s already hurting you, in fact. So remember that. Staying out of inertia doesn’t make it painless. In fact, staying with someone because you're afraid of hurting them is often a much slower and more confusing way of hurting them.

I say this as someone who has lived through it many times. My first real relationship was similar to yours. I loved her, we had three years together, and I couldn’t break up with her outright, so I did it slowly, over the course of a year. I even moved out of our apartment and still didn’t break up with her! I thought I was being kinder by making the ending gradual. I wasn't. I was just postponing the pain while creating a much longer period of agony for both of us.

Let’s circle back to your guilt, because you might need to hear it one more time: You don't owe her a relationship because she forgave you.

You made a mistake, she decided what she wanted to do about it, and the two of you continued the relationship. Her generosity at the time was a gift, not a debt you now have to repay with your own unhappiness.

Speaking of happiness, you absolutely can and should build up your social life, like as soon as possible — not as a reason to leave more easily — but as a thing you need for yourself period. Join things. Go to those happy hours after work. Find a recreational kickball league or an amigurumi class or a weird little local group of people who are into whatever you enjoy. Reconnect with people from your past. Become a regular somewhere. Your romantic partner should never be your entire social infrastructure for lots of reasons, but a big one is this: When we don’t have a solid foundation of a social/emotional support system, it can sometimes be really hard to tell the difference between choosing someone and needing them.

But don't make yourself wait until you've assembled a perfect support network before you allow yourself to leave. Loneliness is painful and friends lessen it somewhat, but not having them isn’t a reason to stay in a relationship you don't want to be in.

That said, because she is currently your entire social world, it might help to make a post-breakup plan for yourself. Decide ahead of time where you'll stay if you need a space, who you'll call, and what you're going to do during the hours you would normally spend together.

Not gonna lie, the short-term pain of a breakup is immensely challenging. You'll miss her. She’s a huge part of your life. You'll feel strange and lonely and bored. You’ll question yourself and your decisions. You’ll have nights when you desperately want to text her or see her.

None of that means you've made the wrong decision. It means you've lost someone important and are grieving that loss. (And this isn’t to say you won’t ever be in each other’s lives again or even friends, but don’t expect it to happen right away. You can’t shortcut the process.)

Then, eventually, slowly, with time and distance and space, you’ll begin to figure out who you are outside of this relationship. That's another part you're afraid of. It's also a huge opportunity.

So do the hard, terrible thing and break up. Do it as kindly as you can. Don't tell her you'll maybe get back together someday. Tell her the truth: You care about her, you're grateful for what you've shared, and you've realized you don't want to continue the relationship.

You're two young people discovering that loving someone and choosing to stay with them are not always the same thing. It’s not a failure. It’s growing up.

Don't spend the next several years trying to earn your way out of a relationship you already know you don't want.

You don't have to make anyone the villain to leave. You don't have to prove the relationship was bad. You don't have to wait until you're 100% certain. You just have to be honest. And then you have to be brave enough to live with the fact that honesty sometimes hurts.

©2026 Tribune Content Agency, LLC.