'oh, Good, You Brought That Pie No One Likes. Again.'
DEAR MISS MANNERS: Every year we host a Thanksgiving meal in our home for approximately 20 family members. The majority of the expense for food and supplies falls on us, and that is OK! We do the "bring a dish" method and it works well.
There is one person who insists on bringing a dessert that no one likes. We have kindly requested they bring something else, and they decline. We have hoped they would see that no one eats what they are bringing, but that doesn't seem to bother them.
They take home what they brought and proudly proclaim they get to eat it all by themselves all week. They also take home large amounts of other leftovers. They don't contribute anything else food-wise, don't help with the setup or cleaning, and are the first person to leave every year.
It's not worth causing unnecessary drama by hurting their feelings. At the same time, this is rather obnoxious, self-centered behavior on their part. Is there a polite and delicate way to address this issue?
GENTLE READER: This clever person has found a way to get credit for bringing something they have every intention of eating themselves -- in addition to snagging free leftovers.
The only solution to this -- and one which Miss Manners is afraid will cause more work for you -- is to declare a "don't bring a dish" method this year. And then let everyone know that you have intentions for those leftovers.
DEAR MISS MANNERS: My husband and I very much enjoy hosting dinners for family and friends, and I always look forward with great anticipation to planning the menu, making the yearly favorites and feeding a crowd. But as Thanksgiving approaches, I am faced once again with a dilemma involving my sister-in-law.
She is quite managerial and thinks nothing of barging into my kitchen to "help." But the real issue is her insistence on bringing dishes that were not requested nor needed, and that no one except her wants to eat. This year we are a much smaller group, but Edie told me to "make less food" so she can bring her own stuffing and mashed potatoes. I suppose it would not be so offensive if she were a halfway decent cook.
The bottom line is, I feel it is quite rude to insist on bringing food to an event that you are not hosting. She did the same last year, and also tried to completely rearrange the seating and placement of buffet dishes, etc., to something she felt was more pleasing.
In the interest of family harmony, can you suggest anything other than an overconsumption of alcohol as a solution?
GENTLE READER: But that is Thanksgiving tradition.
Tell Edie that you are happy to share hosting duties, but that it must be done year to year, not in the middle of yours. You will plan your menu and set your table as you see fit, and when she hosts, she can do the same.
Miss Manners has no idea if this is even an option -- or if Edie will be amenable -- but the conversation itself will provide a chance for her to back off and tend to her own turkey.
========
(Please send your questions to Miss Manners at her website, www.missmanners.com; to her email, gentlereader@missmanners.com; or through postal mail to Miss Manners, Andrews McMeel Syndication, 1130 Walnut St., Kansas City, MO 64106.)
Copyright 2026 Judith Martin
COPYRIGHT 2026 JUDITH MARTIN













Comments