Entertainment

/

ArcaMax

Review: 'Much Ado About Nothing' becomes an irresistible pink confetti musical on Broadway

Chris Jones, Chicago Tribune on

Published in Entertainment News

NEW YORK — Selling Shakespeare in a giant Broadway barn like the Winter Garden Theatre requires some really slick shtick these days. Enter the inestimably shrewd British director Jamie Lloyd, the audacious theatrical monarch of the one, really great idea, who has decided that “Much Ado About Nothing,” actually a complex and restless play, is an optimistic, big-hearted romp, all about love, sweet love.

As viewed through a giant tornado of paper pink petals tumbling constantly from the heavens.

And with Margaret (Mason Alexander Park), traditionally a mere waiting-gentlewoman and functionary of the plot, elevated to become our fabulous musical cabaret host.

The first thing we hear is not Leonato nattering on about some letter (boring), but Park singing “I feel the night explode when we’re together / emotion overload in the heat of pleasure.” That’s Taylor Dane rather than Shakespeare, but it sure sets the vibe Lloyd wants. And Park has plenty more to belt, including All-4-One’s “I Swear,” rendered here as a retro singalong with Gen X women firmly in the show’s target demographic.

Party on wIth Beatrice and Benedick! Dance in the aisles! Feel the joy! Celebrate the sophistication of middle-aged love!

There is, in fact, so much of that confetti that you don’t actually notice that the show otherwise has no set, beyond a couple of tables and a giant inflatable heart, which at one point seems to be attacking Tom Hiddleston’s Benedick like it’s Audrey II in “Little Shop of Horrors.”

This is, for sure, Hiddleston’s night in a way that might be a jolt for Broadway audiences who last saw this most versatile of British actors in Harold Pinter’s “Betrayal.” Lloyd preaches the gospel of hyper-conversational, hyper-interactive Shakespeare and Hiddleston happily eroticizes and objectives himself, gamely pitching his considerable charms at the single ladies, or the single for-the-night ladies, in the front row of the audience.

Based on what I saw, they are more than happy to play along. To wit:

Benedick: “I am loved of all ladies.”Audience member (loudly): “Hello? Hello?”

Hayley Atwell’s Beatrice, although rather more muted throughout, does also get a go, seeking out the minority of dudes in the orchestra on, “Show me where the bachelors sit.”

 

But it’s Hiddleston who seems of most interest to a director who understands the pleasures to be had for the audience by coaxing him and his well-manicured beard to boogie through this particular pink wonderland. Better yet, Lloyd also has a star who can make perfect sense of this language and ensure it sounds freshly minted on the tongue. Atwell is similarly well-spoken, although there is no question who is the star of this particular love match; in most productions of my experience, it has been the other way around.

Is this the most complicated “Much Ado” you ever saw? Absolutely not. Does it care much about the Claudio/Hero subplot that eventually unlocks the vulnerabilities of Beatrice and Benedick, allowing them to fall in love? Nope, although it does beautifully capture the ultimate melancholy of Don Pedro (Gerald Kyd). Why is he sad? ‘Cause he has no love, silly.

That subtler “Prince thou art sad, get thee a wife” moment between Benedick and Don Pedro actually felt to me like the most authentic of the entire show, but that is not what most people will be posting on social media. Not with all that pink confetti around.

One of the central problems of this play for a modern audience is that the blameless Hero (Mara Huf) has to immediately forgive Claudio (James Phoon), who was duped by the shady Don John (Tim Steed) into thinking her unfaithful and literally abandoning her at the altar. I’ve seen directors tie themselves in knots trying to justify that. Not here. Lloyd has Huf give Phoon a little punch of pique, drawing a few hoots and hollers from the women in the audience, and then jump immediately into his arms, being as love conquers all, or something like that.

By that point, of course, we well know the theme of the night; we are, after all, looking at designer Soutra Gilmour’s giant inflatable heart, rather like a suburban Valentine’s Day decoration on steroids.

On the nose? For sure. But at the Winter Garden, all resistance is futile.

———

At the Winter Garden Theatre, 1634 Broadway, New York; muchadobroadway.com

———


©2026 Chicago Tribune. Visit chicagotribune.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus