Entertainment

/

ArcaMax

Review: 'I Play Rocky,' stirring story of the making of 'Rocky,' is a knockout

Adam Graham, The Detroit News on

Published in Entertainment News

If 1976's "Rocky" is an underdog tale for the ages, "I Play Rocky" is its worthy counterpart, a making-of story that goes blow-for-blow, round-for-round with the original big screen success story. It's just as rousing as "Rocky," but in a different way.

"I Play Rocky" focuses on the oft-told behind-the-scenes story of how "Rocky" came to be, and how a young Sylvester Stallone bet on himself to make the movie the way he wanted to make it. It's a down-the-middle, undeniable crowd-pleaser, a movie that plays better the more you let your guard down and give yourself over to its charms.

Anthony Ippolito plays Sylvester Stallone in a dead-on impression of Sly that's so uncanny it's remarkable. In the movie's first scene, which sees the young actor auditioning for a role, the voice and the likeness are so close to Sly it's almost distracting. But by the next scene it clicks, and from then on, it feels just like watching Stallone onscreen.

Peter Gamble's script focuses on the young Stallone's attempts to launch his acting career, and writing himself a role so that he can carve his own path in Hollywood. He finally settles on a script about a boxer after watching Chuck Wepner go 15 rounds with Muhammad Ali on TV while at a bar, and being moved by the underdog's tale in real time.

AnnaSophia Robb plays Stallone's girlfriend Sasha, and if "I Play Rocky" has a weakness, it's the way she and other women (including Kiki Seto, who plays Talia Shire) are cast to the side of the story and aren't given much to do but support Sly's dreams. Matt Dillon plays Stallone's father, Frank, who wants to see his son succeed.

"I Play Rocky" picks up steam as Stallone pitches his script to Irwin Winkler (P.J. Byrne) and Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell), the producing partners who would help put "Rocky" in motion. But they have to answer to Sandy Maddox (a hilarious Tracy Letts), a vindictive studio exec, who is standing in for several unnamed executives at United Artists who are continually trying to buy Stallone out of starring in the project. Each time the dollar figure gets raised Stallone's gamble on himself increases, and the escalating prices become their own running joke.

Jay Duplass joins as "Rocky" director John G. Avildsen, as "I Play Rocky" switches over to become a sort-of composite of "Rocky's" greatest hits.

These scenes — including the classic scene were Rocky runs up the steps outside the Philadelphia Museum of Art, and Rocky hurling right hooks at slabs of beef inside a freezing meat truck while being interviewed by eventual WXYZ-TV legend Diana Lewis — are so ingrained in popular culture and in movie montages from over the years that you don't necessarily have to know "Rocky" to know them, and "I Play Rocky" cashes in on their cultural cachet, using them as shorthand for the magic the movie created.

It's a cheat code, sure, but what is "I Play Rocky" if not an outright homage to its source material?

Director Peter Farrelly ("Green Book") brings an honest, uncynical spirit to "I Play Rocky" that makes it nearly as uplifting as the original "Rocky." Farrelly's solo projects have been a mixed bag — "The Greatest Beer Run Ever" was sincere to a fault, "Ricky Stanicky" was a straight-up stinker — but his earnestness as a filmmaker is a good match for this material, and his warm, open-hearted approach is the right fit for the "Rocky" tale.

 

"I Play Rocky" even has a cute dog role, and is unabashed in milking it for all it's worth. Not all the movie's facts align with the real "Rocky" story — including those involving the dog — but for the purposes of this story, that's not a deal-breaker.

The movie's emotional high point arrives at its end when people are finally watching "Rocky," and in that way the story not only celebrates the creative process behind the camera but also the power of watching movies and allowing yourself to be moved by them. There's a lot of reflexivity in being moved watching people being moved by an underdog story inside the making of said underdog story, but don't fight it. However you score it, "I Play Rocky" is a knockout.

———

'I PLAY ROCKY'

Grade: A-

MPA rating: PG-13 (for strong language, brief sexual material, and smoking)

Running time: 2:08

How to watch: In theaters nationwide Nov. 20

———


©2026 The Detroit News. Visit detroitnews.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus