Families in Kentucky's Fayette County go to trial over law limiting pronoun, restroom use for trans students
Published in News & Features
LEXINGTON, Ky. — A trial in Fayette Circuit Court this week will decide whether parents of transgender students in Fayette County Public Schools are correct in arguing that a Kentucky law passed in 2023 targeting trans students is unconstitutional.
The controversial Republican-backed Senate Bill 150 passed in 2023 despite Democratic Gov. Andy Beshear’s veto. It bans gender-affirming healthcare for trans minors, restricts classroom teachings on gender and sexuality, prohibits districts and schools from asking teachers and staff to use a trans student’s pronouns, and mandates districts create policies that prevent trans students from using restrooms that align with their gender identity.
The 2023 lawsuit filed against Fayette County Public Schools and the Kentucky Attorney General’s office takes aim at the latter two restrictions, and asks Fayette Circuit Court Judge Julie Goodman to block them from being enforced.
In September 2023, some Lexington transgender children and their families filed the class-action lawsuit in Fayette Circuit Court challenging the GOP-backed law’s pronoun and bathroom requirements in public schools.
The lawsuit challenges the constitutionality of the educational provisions in SB 150. It asks the court to enter a judgment declaring SB 150’s educational provisions unconstitutional. The suit also wants the court to enjoin the Fayette County Board of Education and the Kentucky Attorney General’s office from enforcing or implementing those SB 150 portions, and order them to comply with the students’ civil rights.
A bench trial is being held in Goodman’s courtroom, which means there will be no jury. Goodman will rule on the case.
Each of the plaintiffs, aged 10 to 17, attended FCPS. They claimed the law violates their fundamental right to public education, their individual right to privacy, free speech, freedom of thought and rights of conscience.
Ernesto Scorsone, a former state lawmaker and former Fayette Circuit judge, told the Herald-Leader Tuesday that he is on the board of Just Fund Kentucky, an educational non-profit organization supporting the families who are challenging the statute.
Scorsone said, “the local school system, their hands are tied because of the statute.”
FCPS lawyers have made similar statements in court documents.
In one court response, FCPS officials said the district’s inability to permit a transgender child to “continue to use the girls’ restroom is due to the SB 150 mandate regarding restrooms, and the fact that FCPS is legally obligated to comply with state law.”
The school district “endeavors to create a welcoming, respectful, and productive learning environment for all FCPS schoolchildren while navigating statutory obligations,” the court response said.
Court documents show that both Fayette Interim Superintendent Bill Bradford and school board Chairman Tyler Murphy are on the witness list for the trial.
One parent, a court document said, decided she is unable to provide testimony at trial because of what she “anticipates would be the inordinate stress involved in doing so, primarily, for her SB150-impacted FCPS middle-school age student,” court documents say.
“Obviously the families feel that the statute is unconstitutional,” said Scorsone. “Trans kids need to be protected. It’s a matter of safety. They need to be protected just like every other child in the school system. And they need to be treated with respect. The provisions of the statute that say none of the kids in the school system can be educated about the fact that there are LGBT folks in society is a preposterous position.”
“If we are to prepare kids for the outside world, for society, how can we hide or act as if gay people don’t exist? It is a ridiculous, preposterous provision in the statute,” Scorsone said.
_____
©2026 Lexington Herald-Leader. Visit kentucky.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments