Dad's dark secret coming out could explain Meghan and Harry's hasty UK return, experts say
Published in News & Features
Suspicion is growing among some royal journalists that Meghan Markle and Prince Harry may have known since the early summer that her estranged older half-brother was about to publicly reveal the “dark secret” about their father’s alleged pedophilia and collections of child pornography, and that’s why they suddenly moved back to the United Kingdom in August.
“I believe they moved back knowing full well what was coming, knowing full well that this had been brewing in the background for several months,” said royal author Tom Sykes on his The Royalist Substack.
Since the Duke and Duchess of Sussex surprised the world by leaving California and landing back in the United Kingdom on Aug. 26, royal observers have feverishly speculated on why they hastily uprooted their young children, 7 and 5, from the only home they have known and returned to a country they spent the past six years depicting as unsafe and hostile.
There have been theories that they returned to England because they failed to realize their American dream of being rich and powerful media moguls, or that they are running out of money and need the proximity of the royal family to give them relevance, as journalist Dan Wakeford reported on his Celebrity Intelligence YouTube channel. Insiders also said Harry missed England, while others said he also missed being a professional royal and wants back in “The Firm.”
But now Sykes and other royal experts say the scandal involving Thomas Markle, Meghan’s once-adored 82-year-old father, could better explain the surprise timing of their return, especially in the wake of his Nov. 6 arrest by the FBI on child pornography charges.
Charlotte Griffiths, editor-at-large of the Mail on Sunday, said in an interview this week with YouTuber Kinsey Schofield that she couldn’t believe that the allegations against Thomas Markle hit so soon after Meghan and Harry returned to the U.K., amid all the other talk about them wanting to relaunch their personal brand. Griffiths agreed it’s possible that the “incoming bomb that was about to explode from (Meghan’s) half brother” was the real reason behind their return. “Everything everything makes sense in a whole new light. I mean, talk about reframing,” she said.
Schofield similarly said on another of her shows this week that the Thomas Markle allegations “totally changed my opinion of why they were back in the U.K.”
For those fixated on the Thomas Markle theory of Harry and Meghan’s return, it is bolstered by growing questions over Meghan’s conflicting public statements about her relationship with her father over the years, including calling herself “daddy’s girl my whole life” in her and Harry’s 2022 Netflix documentary. She also repeatedly blamed the media for causing their estrangement.
Then last month, right after news broke about her father, Meghan revealed that she actually ended her relationship with him in either 2018 or 2019, after she said she learned about his alleged abuse from a letter sent to the Metropolitan Police by her father’s first ex-wife. The lifestyle influencer said she had been advised to not say anything publicly about the allegations and was assured that some police agency was investigating. But there was no investigation, and Meghan never said she tried to follow up and learn why.
Amid the questions of “What Meghan knew and when,” and why she stayed silent for seven years, Sykes and others have pointed out the advantages to her and Harry of being back in his home country — now that the allegations against her father have become public and he has been arrested by the FBI on child pornography charges.
In the U.K., Meghan can keep her distance from the FBI, despite what her representatives have told the Sunday Times about her wanting to cooperate, Sykes said.
“I am sure Meghan doesn’t want to be interviewed by the FBI, which might explain the hasty departure from California, and the last-minute decision to stay here for Christmas when they are not welcome,” Sykes said.
The couple also can rely on the U.K.’s more protective privacy laws to shield them from intrusive and uncomfortable media scrutiny, Sykes and other royal experts say. If they were still in Montecito when news broke about her father, the street leading to their gated community could conceivably be crowded with reporters, news cameras and paparazzi, Schofield said. But in the U.K., they can hide out on their billionaire friend’s Cotswolds estate and “for the most part, they have been left alone,” Schofield said.
As for Sykes’ contention that they are staying in the U.K. for Christmas but “are not welcome,” he is referring to reports this week that Harry, Meghan and their children, Archie and Lilibet, will spend the holidays in England, instead of returning to California, as originally planned. And, as much as the couple’s P.R. team said that Harry’s return to the U.K. could facilitate his reconciliation with his estranged family, there has been no indication he has been granted an audience with his father, King Charles III. He and Meghan also have been shut out of his estranged family’s Christmas gathering at Sandringham, according to Daily Mail writer Alison Boshof, who said that relations between Harry and his brother, Prince William, remain especially cold.
Sykes is among those who resist reports from People magazine and other outlets that try to sympathetically portray Meghan as a distraught daughter who has been blindsided by horrific news about her father. He accused the former Hollywood TV actress of being “performative” and of trying to look “upset and drained” as she joined Harry at an online child safety event at the European Parliament in Brussels last week.
“The reality is that she has known about this for seven years,” Sykes said. “What has actually changed is that it has come out. Everyone else now knows her family’s dark secret.”
The child-abuse and -pornography allegations against Meghan’s father first exploded into the global consciousness on Oct. 23 — about nine weeks after Meghan and Harry landed back in the U.K. On Oct. 23, The Sun tabloid exclusively reported that Meghan’s older half-brother, Thomas Markle Jr., discovered a trove of alleged child sex abuse material in four boxes that his father had stored near his home in the Philippines. Markle and his son moved to the Southeast Asian country in early 2025.
Markle Jr. said he had actually discovered the stash of disturbing content months earlier, after his father left the Philippines in May 2026 and moved back to the United States. The elder Markle had suffered a stroke and a blood clot which led to his left leg being amputated in December 2025.
After making the discovery, Markle Jr. told The Sun he contacted an FBI hotline on July 10, as well as the U.S.-based National Center for Exploited and Missing Children. But Markle Jr. said he received no calls or follow-up inquiries.
Meanwhile, it’s not clear when Markle Jr. first contacted The Sun about his discovery, but Sykes and other royal journalists have theorized that Meghan’s 60-year-old brother could have gotten in touch with Meghan at some point over the summer to let her know about their father’s collection. Sykes said it’s even possible that Markle Jr. contacted Meghan before he contacted the FBI. Markle Jr. also would not have contacted his sister for altruistic reasons, but because “we know that he is venal and we know that he is out for money,” Sykes said.
It’s also possible that The Sun reached out to Meghan and Harry for comment as it was reporting on Markle Jr.’s discovery, said Tom Bower, the author of two books on Harry and Meghan. In a conversation with Schofield on her YouTube show, Bower said, “I’m sure (The Sun) put it to Meghan, and I’m sure Thomas Markle (Jr.) told Meghan about it, and (they figured) it’s safer for them in England than in America. I mean, they’re secluded here.”
In perhaps a strange coincidence, Sykes and others also noted that July 10 is the day that Harry, Meghan and their children had tea with the king at his Highgrove country estate, while they were visiting the U.K. for a series of events related to Harry’s Invictus Games. It’s never been reported what the couple and the king discussed, or whether Harry and Meghan told his father that they planned to move back to the U.K. Griffiths said the palace claimed it didn’t know about their plans ahead of time.
“The Sussexes conveniently make a trip to the U.K. in July where they meet with King Charles, and they start trying to lay the groundwork for this move,” said Schofield. “And then they suddenly pop back up in the U.K,. where Harry told us it was way too unsafe for him to bring his wife and children, and now they’re living there. And I just wonder if maybe they could feel this storm brewing and thought, ‘It’s best that we be in the U.K., where there are probably stronger guidelines when it comes to paparazzi (and) just more respect for that royal proximity in the U.K. than there is in the United States.”
But if that July 10 tea was seen as a sign that Charles was open to reconciling with his son, the king’s reported unwillingness to see him and his wife since their return suggests he may want to keep his distance, especially since the allegations against Thomas Markle have become public, both Schofield and Griffiths said.
The U.S. Department of Justice announced on Nov. 6 that it had found more alleged child sex abuse materials in two storage lockers that Markle maintained near his former home in Los Angeles. The materials included images of an adult man — identified as Markle — with a nude, prepubescent girl, allegedly in the Philippines. The materials also included photos of Markle with children in various stages of undress.
That day, FBI agents arrested Meghan’s father at his senior-living home near Tampa, Florida. News photos showed FBI agents pushing a handcuffed Markle in a wheelchair to a waiting ambulance. The retired Hollywood lighting designer soon appeared in federal court where he was charged with one count of possessing child pornography. He is expected to remain in federal custody until his trial.
This week, police in the Philippines announced they also have filed charges against Markle, related to the boxes of material found by his son. The Philippine National Police announced that they had charged him with two counts of offering, distributing, selling, exporting, or importing any form of child sexual abuse or exploitation material and one count of possessing child sexual abuse or exploitation material, law enforcement sources told People magazine.
©2026 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit at mercurynews.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.








Comments