Pennsylvania pension fund may sue its consultant for botching profits figure

Joseph N. DiStefano, The Philadelphia Inquirer on

Published in Business News

Pennsylvania's beleaguered pension fund for educators has hired yet another outside law firm — this time to consider suing the consulting firm that admitted botching a key profits calculation in an error that has triggered an ongoing FBI investigation.

The board of the $75 billion pension plan has hired the big Philadelphia firm of Blank Rome to pursue "potential litigation" following the admission from consultant Aon that its "inadvertent clerical mistakes" led the fund to adopt a false and exaggerated figure for profits.

The plan — the Public School Employees' Retirement System — later had to correct that number, forcing 100,000 school employees to pay more into the pension plan. Under the state "risk share" law, how much teachers pay into the fund depends partly on its investment profits.

PSERS had agreed to pay the Chicago-based Aon $7.2 million for investment advice and performance measurements in contracts dating back almost a decade — — and the fund continues to employ the firm. But Aon's contract also includes a promise to repay "all claims" that may result from failure to comply with its terms.

Aon had no comment. Early last year, the firm said "human error" and mistakes in data entry had caused "data corruption." "Aon sincerely regrets the error," the firm wrote the pension plan.

PSERS would not elaborate on hiring Blank Rome. People familiar with the decision said the law firm will review options forlegal action, including a possible lawsuit against Aon.


After the retirement system made the mistake public last spring, the U.S. Attorney's office in Philadelphia sent FBI agents with subpoenas to learn more about what went wrong. The Securities and Exchange Commission is also investigating the miscalculation, as well as possible gifts by Wall Street advisers to PSERS employees, and whether that influenced pension contracts.

The embarrassing error fueled dissent and tensions on the board. The fund's two top executives announced their retirement last fall. No one has been charged with wrongdoing.

Even before Monday's board vote to hire Blank Rome, the pension system had paid out $4.5 million to at least seven other law firms and a financial consultant brought on to deal with the faulty calculation and the federal probes that have grown to include the Securities and Exchange Commission. The biggest single payment — $1.9 million so far — has gone to the Philadelphia firm of Morgan, Lewis & Bockius to deal directly with the federal investigators.

Because of the law linking profits to payments by teachers and other school employees, the profit figure was a source of great anxiety for the fund. The original calculation had wrongly pumped up PSERS revenues by $150 million — just enough, it seemed, for the fund to avoid increasing payments from working educators. Then, when the figure was corrected, levies rose for educators.


swipe to next page
©2022 The Philadelphia Inquirer, LLC. Visit at Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


blog comments powered by Disqus