Sports

/

ArcaMax

Jaxon Smith-Njigba for NFL MVP? How Seahawks receiver can defy history.

Bob Condotta, The Seattle Times on

Published in Football

SEATTLE — Jaxon Smith-Njigba took a seat on the bench last Sunday in Las Vegas and began catching his breath after his latest signature play in a season filled with them when backup quarterback Jalen Milroe approached.

“You’re good at football, Milroe told Smith-Njigba in a scene captured by NFL Films. “You’re really good at football. Like, really good."

And maybe — as the temptation increases to find new and creative ways to explain how Smith-Njigba does what he does as the numbers, records and accolades have piled up — it’s just that simple.

Smith-Njigba is just “really good at football."

Or as Seahawks coach Mike Macdonald said recently: “He’s tremendous. I don’t know how else to describe him."

How about this way: NFL MVP candidate.

After Smith-Njigba recorded 171 receiving yards in Sunday’s 21-13 win over the Raiders and remained on pace for the first 2,000-plus yard season in NFL history, some began to wonder if he could buck historical trends and become a legitimate part of the MVP conversation.

No receiver has been named MVP since The Associated Press first handed out the award in 1961 (the NFL recognizes the AP award as its official award).

And only three non-quarterbacks have won the award since 2000 and none since Minnesota running back Adrian Peterson in 2012, when he rushed for 2,097 yards — second most in league history.

The closest a receiver has come to being named MVP is Jerry Rice of the 49ers in 1987, when he finished second to Denver quarterback John Elway.

Rice scored 22 touchdowns in a season in which he played just 12 games, in part due to a players' strike. Elway got 36 votes to Rice’s 30 while Joe Montana received 18.

No receiver even got a vote from 1999-2020, during the era when voters simply picked one MVP and that was it, including Detroit’s Calvin Johnson in 2012 when he set the current record for receiving yards in a season with 1,964. Peterson won it that season with Denver QB Peyton Manning the only other player to get votes.

The format changed in 2022 allowing for voters to pick a top five based on a 10-5-3-2-1 point system, which has meant as many as 15 players receiving votes in a season.

But even with that format, Smith-Njigba did not get an MVP vote last year even though he was named the Offensive Player of the Year (Rams QB Matthew Stafford was the MVP), and the highest a receiver has finished since then is fifth — Minnesota’s Justin Jefferson in 2022 when he had 1,809 receiving yards.

But maybe, some wonder, Smith-Njigba could be the one to at least cause voters to think long and hard.

Announcer and podcaster Mike Golic Jr. said on "The Bill Barnwell Show" on ESPN this week that while the history of the award indicates receivers need not really apply, that it “shouldn’t be shocking" for JSN to be considered.

"To actually reward a guy who is playing an insane level of football (even) with all the focus on him, (playing with) different quarterbacks, and it doesn’t matter," Golic said.

Barnwell noted Smith-Njigba is 10th this week in DraftKings’ betting odds at 80-1 (Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow is the favorite followed by Bills QB Josh Allen and 49ers QB Brock Purdy).

“He is a longshot,’’ Barnwell said. “He is also playing out of his damn mind."

 

What would it take for Smith-Njigba to have a real shot at the award?

“(He’s) going to need a ‘first since’ or ‘first ever’ kind of number associated with him and the quarterbacks playing bad (the rest of the way)," Golic said.

Barnwell said it might take even more.

“2K is the starting point," Barnwell said. “I don’t think he has a shot unless he becomes the first receiver in NFL history to rack up 2,000 yards in a season. … I don’t think that would be enough (but) that would initially get himself in the conversation. But unless the Seahawks are the one seed or make this huge run to the NFC title and JSN’s catching passes every week, I don’t think 2K would be enough. But if he gets significantly far enough away from the Calvin Johnsons (and) the guys of the past, if it’s like 2,200 yards and 18 touchdowns, that sort of number where it’s such an incredible outlier, I think you have a realistic case at that point."

One could, of course, question why it’s so hard for receivers to become part of the NFL MVP conversation, especially as passing has become a bigger part of the game over the last few decades.

The reasoning has typically been that receivers just don’t touch the ball as much as QBs and running backs — Smith-Njigba’s 79 receptions are 12.7% of Seattle’s total offensive plays this season. Still, that number only further accentuates his contribution — his 1,207 yards account for 36.2% of Seattle’s offense.

But as teams’ reliance on passing has increased over the 65 years since the award began, voters have tended to increasingly favor the guy pulling the trigger and not those catching the passes.

From 1961-2000, 16 non-QBs won the award, including a defensive lineman (Minnesota’s Alan Page in 1971), a linebacker (Lawrence Taylor of the New York Giants in 1986) and even a kicker (Washington’s Mark Moseley in the strike year of 1982 when he made 20 of 21 field goals).

The other non-QBs during that period were all running backs.

But since 2001 it’s been all quarterbacks other than Seattle’s Shaun Alexander in 2005 — the only Seahawk to win the award — San Diego’s LaDainian Tomlinson in 2006 and Peterson in 2012.

From 1980-2021 only four WRs even got votes — Rice, Randy Moss, Sterling Sharpe and Cooper Kupp in 2021 with the Rams. (Seattle’s Steve Largent received two votes in 1979 when there were 84 voters. The AP settled on 50 voters in 1999 after there had once been as many as 94 voters.)

The compromise has tended to be what happened last year — Stafford won the MVP vote and then Smith-Njigba won the Offensive Player of the Year honor (for which Stafford got only three votes, voters apparently knowing he’d be the MVP and didn’t need to win both).

In fact, no QB — oddly — has been the Offensive Player of the Year since Patrick Mahomes in 2018, despite only QBs winning the MVP during that time.

History indicates that’s probably what will happen again — a QB as MVP and a non-QB as OPOY.

Winning that again would put JSN in rarefied air. Only two players have repeated as OPOY since the award was first handed out in 1973 — Houston running back Earl Campbell from 1978-80 and Rams running back Marshall Faulk from 1999-2001.

Smith-Njigba, though, has some competition for that award as Detroit running back Jahmyr Gibbs — who has 1,000 yards rushing and 11 TDs and also 41 receptions for 384 yards and two TDs — is the current betting line favorite with Smith-Njigba a close second and Kansas City running back Kenneth Walker III a distant third.

That this is all a discussion, however, only reinforces that Smith-Njigba is indeed “really good at football.


© 2026 The Seattle Times. Visit www.seattletimes.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus