Sports

/

ArcaMax

Andrew Callahan: What I got wrong about the 2026 Patriots

Andrew Callahan, Boston Herald on

Published in Football

BOSTON — It’s a ghost town right now at Patriots headquarters.

The Pats are on their bye, an annual time for rest, recovery and reflection.

The roster is so wounded Mike Vrabel and Eliot Wolf might trade a future seventh-round pick for another week off if they could. Not me.

I am eager to see the Patriots’ resolve at a time of identity crisis without Drake Maye, and discover how they plan to resolve their issues on defense and elsewhere. But first, it’s time for my own reflection.

Presenting my third annual “what I got wrong about the Patriots” column because, as always, accountability should be a two-way street.

1. Drake Maye will make a Year 3 leap

Tough break.

Pun, painfully, intended.

But even before his ankle injury, Maye did not reach, let alone pass, the bar he set in 2025. Not by Expected Points Added (EPA) per play, nor success rate, advanced accuracy metrics, passer rating, completion percentage or yards per attempt. His turnover rate was also more than double last year’s, a jump traceable to his first three games when some wondered if the 24-year-old budding superstar was broken. He had one touchdown to six interceptions.

Maye, of course, was not broken. Statistically, he turned around and was the best quarterback in football from Weeks 4-8, before a three-touchdown, three-interception performance versus the Packers. Then, the injury bug bit — hard.

But that doesn’t offset my, um, bold proclamation from Sept. 6: “The best of Drake Maye has yet to come. And it is coming. Mark it down. Save this story. Print the tweet and shove it in my face if you must come January, but Maye will make another leap. A Year 3 leap, starting Wednesday night in Seattle.”

Maye had three interceptions in a game three days later. Nice going, Callahan.

2. The Patriots’ biggest weakness is edge defender

Oh no.

In the Herald’s training camp preview this summer, I picked this position as the weakest on the team.

“If (Elijah) Ponder doesn’t break out, the Patriots are in serious trouble at outside linebacker. (Harold) Landry is a 30-year-old coming off a major knee injury, and the projected starter opposite him, Dre’Mont Jones, is more steady than spectacular. Second-round rookie Gabe Jacas remained unsigned as of Thursday evening and missed all spring practices.”

About that …

Ponder is tied for seventh-most sacks in the NFL with 7.5. He, Jacas and Jones all rank in the top 40 of pass-rush grades among all edge defenders at Pro Football Focus. Jacas is 15th (!), ahead of Maxx Crosby, Andrew Van Ginkel and Danielle Hunter. Jacas ranks even higher by pass-rush win percentage.

Jones had the Patriots’ first sack of the season and tallied four QB hits at Seattle, then injured his shoulder the following week against Pittsburgh. He’s since played through that injury and missed just a single game while also dealing with a hurt foot and cramps last weekend. Lately, this group has been at its best, pushing the Pats to the league’s No. 6 ranking by pressure rate with a four-man rush.

Credit to these three and outside linebackers coach Mike Smith for proving folks like me wrong. Dead wrong.

 

3. A.J. Brown will have a Pro Bowl season

Sheesh.

This was a take I shared mostly on my podcast, "Pats Interference," and on TV and radio. I believed Brown would easily surpass 1,000 yards, flashing his 2024 form, not the player who slowed down last year with the Eagles. Brown has instead come to almost a grinding halt.

Injuries are to blame, but when some of those include a knee condition that has flared up and may be fast-tracking the end of his prime, if not career, it’s hard to call this take (and trade) anything but a swing and a miss.

4. The Patriots will play faster

OK, I am only taking partial blame for this one.

Back in August, I reported and wrote a story about the Patriots’ plan to play faster on offense, which included quotes from Vrabel, Maye, Brown, Reggie Gilliam and Hunter Henry. One of the details included in that story was offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels declaring on Day 1 of OTAs that the Pats would hurry to the line after an explosive play to catch defenses off-guard.

Earlier this season, after a long pass play, they were flagged for delay of game. Oh, and they ranked in the bottom 10 of offensive pace (defined as average number of seconds per play).

Nowadays, they are up to 15th, but this was a miss, even if the benefits of going up-tempo occasionally are obvious.

“It just throws the defense off a lot, you know, all phases,” Brown said this summer. “I don’t want to get into that.”

Yeah. Me neither.

5. Bold prediction: Kayshon Boutte won’t get traded this summer

Another home run from me in our training camp preview.

Here’s what I wrote back in mid-July: “Recent reporting suggests the Patriots would have flipped Boutte already if they could have received a fifth-round pick for him during the draft. Maybe even a sixth-rounder. Alas, Boutte will stay in New England through the summer, and be convinced to put his best foot forward in a contract year as teams continue to turn their nose up at trading for him.

“And you know what? That’s A-OK. The Patriots, even while armed with their best receiving corps in years, are not in a position to just give away players of Boutte’s caliber, no matter how crowded the depth chart is. He will stay and contribute, then become a hotter name at the trade deadline.”

Yeah, well, have you ever heard of Jaylen Reed?

He’s the safety the Patriots acquired for Boutte back in … late August.

So close.

____


©2026 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit at bostonherald.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus