Sports

/

ArcaMax

Dieter Kurtenbach: The 49ers' awesome offense has a glaring weak link that could derail the season

Dieter Kurtenbach, The Mercury News on

Published in Football

The NFL changes right around Thanksgiving.

For the first two months of the season, coaches treat Sundays like a science fair, trotting out their pet concepts and running their “stuff” regardless of who’s lined up across from them. Then the holiday decorations hit the store shelves, the standings tighten and the league’s finest minds turn into ruthless pragmatists.

Welcome to the button-pushing portion of the schedule, where weak links get exposed and seasons’ hopes go to die.

And right now, the biggest, brightest target on the San Francisco 49ers’ roster is wearing No. 75.

Left guard Connor Colby, in his second season on the 49ers’ offensive line, has proven not just to be a liability in Kyle Shanahan’s high-powered offense, but perhaps a legitimate health hazard for quarterback Brock Purdy.

One game, his brutal performance against the Cowboys on Sunday, tells that story, but it was the continuation of a downward trend since Week 1. A trend that really started when he won the starting left guard job, lost it, and then won and lost it again in training camp.

If you want to understand where the NFL is headed over the next seven weeks and why the Niners’ left guard is now a main character for this team, look at college football. The best coaches in the college ranks aren’t necessarily the ones with the thickest playbooks; they’re the button pushers. They spot an advantage, put a thumb on it, and press that button until the scoreboard breaks.

It’s a byproduct of a simpler game, sure, but it’s mostly born out of existential dread. When a single loss can torch a season, style points are for suckers — you do whatever it takes to survive. (We’ll see if that desperation holds up in the super-expanded playoff era. I hope it does, but I’m not optimistic.)

By late November, that exact same urgency infects the NFL. The combination of higher stakes, more film to study and injuries piling up forces coordinators to stop calling plays in a vacuum and start hunting mismatches.

We saw it on full display last week in Texas, where Dallas quarterback Dak Prescott threw for 343 yards and five touchdowns by relentlessly picking on a banged-up Deommodore Lenoir and a disjointed 49ers secondary. San Francisco survived that 46-40 shootout because Purdy was near-perfect, posting a 154.5 passer rating while piling up 389 yards through the air. The Cowboys defense stunk even more than the Niners’.

But here’s the catch: Purdy was also sacked five times against the Cowboys. And opposing defensive coordinators didn’t need to consult the film to see why.

Like last year, Colby started the season looking like a revelation before fading fast once the league collected enough tape on him. The book is officially out on the second-year guard, and it reads like a horror novel for 49ers fans.

 

He skips assignments on twists and stunts, leaving free rushers a clear runway to the quarterback. He dances around in space instead of anchoring, gets bull-rushed into Purdy’s lap by power, gets beaten off the snap by speed, and spends way too much time staring at the stadium lights from his back.

Against Dallas, Colby surrendered a staggering nine pressures — more than double any other 49ers lineman — including a belly-flop block attempt against Caleb Downs that looked more like a slip-and-slide audition than NFL pass protection.

Does all this come across as harsh? So be it. Is it fair for the columnist to be singing him out? Well, opposing teams are about to do it, relentlessly, and the “F” in NFL never stood for fair.

And if you thought the game against the Cowboys was bad, wait until Sunday night in Mexico City. Minnesota defensive coordinator Brian Flores runs a full-blown chaos defense that will happily blitz 10 guys if he’s feeling saucy. Flores is the ultimate NFL button pusher, and you can bet he has a web of red yarn on his office wall connecting every exotic blitz package straight to No. 75.

Two, three, four guys going right at Colby? Nothing is off limits for the NFL’s preeminent defensive madman.

It doesn’t get any easier a week later at Levi’s Stadium, when the Seahawks bring their more structured, but much heavier brand of defensive violence to Santa Clara.

Both defenses are going to line up across from Colby and press the button until he proves he can stop them.

Maybe Shanahan can scheme around it with quick throws, split-zone runs, and extra tight ends. Maybe Purdy’s magic acts can keep bailing out a leaky pocket. Or maybe Colby suddenly rediscovers the early-season form that made him look like a starting-caliber player.

But watch No. 75 the rest of the way — for as long as he stays in the lineup.

Strange as it might sound, his play is going to tell the story of the 49ers’ season.

____


©2026 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit at mercurynews.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus