Current News

/

ArcaMax

Trial over Kentucky law affecting transgender students is over. Now what?

Taylor Six, Lexington Herald-Leader on

Published in News & Features

LEXINGTON, Ky. — The evidence has concluded for a bench trial that questions the constitutionality of Kentucky Senate Bill 150 — but a decision could be weeks away.

Attorneys closed their testimony Friday afternoon as part of an ongoing trial in Fayette Circuit Court filed by Lexington transgender students and their families that say the bill is unconstitutional. The families have sued the Kentucky Attorney General’s office and Fayette County Public Schools.

The controversial Republican-backed Senate Bill 150 passed in 2023 despite Democratic Gov. Andy Beshear’s veto. It bans gender-affirming healthcare for trans minors, restricts classroom teachings on gender and sexuality, prohibits districts and schools from asking teachers and staff to use a trans student’s pronouns, and mandates districts create policies that prevent trans students from using restrooms that align with their gender identity.

Each of the plaintiffs, aged 10 to 17, attended schools within FCPS. They claim the law violates their fundamental right to public education, their individual right to privacy, free speech, freedom of thought and rights of conscience.

The case began Monday and is being held as a bench trial before Fayette Circuit Judge Julie Muth Goodman. As part of a bench trial, the case is presented only before a judge who will make a decision about the outcome alone.

However, no closing statements are presented like in a criminal trial. Attorneys have 30 days after the evidence is presented to submit written briefs to make their arguments. Their briefings are due Dec. 21.

Goodman would then make a decision based off the evidence and those summary briefs.

Testimony throughout the trial

Goodman heard five days worth of testimony from parents, students and social psychologists who testified how Senate Bill 150 did, or did not, impact students in Fayette County Public Schools.

A school district employee testified that the bill’s passage created confusion and fear among other staff who did not know how to properly, or legally, interact with their students.

Melissa Stewart, a dropout prevention and advocate for student success specialist with Fayette County, testified that teachers and students were fearful about using preferred pronouns, gender-affirming restrooms, and teaching curriculum that promotes diversity to marginalized groups.

Stewart is a current FCPS employee, but she previously worked as a unity specialist with the office of student belonging and success. This office was directly responsible for supporting minority and marginalized groups such as the LGBTQ+, BIPOC and multilingual communities. That office no longer exists within FCPS.

“That marginalized group was no longer able to enter the building and that teachers were able to see them as who they were regardless of anything else to try and learn,” Stewart said Wednesday. “There are less conversations, and fear took hold in the classrooms and everything got a lot quieter.”

A 17-year-old transgender boy and his mother also testified as part of the plaintiff’s witnesses.

Identified under the pseudonym of “Child Noe” he testified about his experiences in school and in school-related activities that affect him after Senate Bill 150 went into effect.

 

As part of Senate Bill 150, Noe is only allowed to use the girls’ restroom, or a gender-neutral restroom. He said he would like the option to use the restroom that affirms his gender identity, and by using only one of three gender-neutral restrooms at his school, he has to wait in line and risk being late to class.

Instead, Noe said he only uses the restroom once a day while at school, if at all. He withholds drinking water so that he does not need to use the restroom while at school.

He outlined other experiences where he went on school trips and was required to sleep in a separate area near the girls because he was biologically born as a girl, despite presenting as a boy.

“It affected me in the way that not only have I lived under this law, but I have lived through it,” Noe said. “I have watched it be developed and added to. I have watched people sit in a room and argue about who I am and who my parents are. They sit in a room and decide I am not smart enough to determine where I relieve myself. It is hurtful, it is shameful.”

Defense experts testified Thursday and Friday that included social psychologists who described how Senate Bill 150 does not impact students in a harmful way.

Attorneys previously asked case be dismissed

Both the Attorney General’s office and the school district asked that the court dismiss the claims after the plaintiffs presented their evidence.

Susan Sears, an attorney for the school district, said the judge should dismiss the claims because the school system was just following the law enacted by the General Assembly, and there’s nothing the district can do.

“(The school district’s) hands are tied, and we are caught in the crosshairs,” Sears said. She said the plaintiffs’ claims were “on-offs” and did not rise to the level of constitutional violations by the district, which was just doing its best to follow the law.

“(The district) turned flips to try and accommodate the law and I cannot think of other relief Fayette County can provide to plaintiffs outside applying the policies that are required by the statute.”

The Attorney General’s office also asked that the claims be dismissed against the office, saying the law wasn’t designed to hinder the transgender students, but to protect the free speech rights of students, teachers and other staff.

“There is no authority in Kentucky that says under state constitution that speech can be compelled from a speaker that believes they are false,” said Aaron Silletto. “(Senate Bill 150) only impacts those who would have a disagreement with those pronouns and preferred names.

Goodman denied their requests. At the close of evidence, Goodman said it was a pleasure to preside over the case. She told attorneys their preparation made a “tough decision” easier to navigate because of the thorough work they did.

_____


©2026 Lexington Herald-Leader. Visit kentucky.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus