Current News

/

ArcaMax

Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court to hear Lindsay Clancy double jeopardy argument in January

Colleen Cronin, Boston Herald on

Published in News & Features

BOSTON — The state’s highest court is set to hear an appeal from Lindsay Clancy’s attorneys in January.

The Duxbury mom was tried over the summer for allegedly murdering her three children, Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, eight months, in January 2023. After a week of deliberations, the jury was deadlocked, 11 to one, with a single holdout concluding she was guilty, leading the judge to declare a mistrial.

Her lawyers argued in a petition to the Supreme Judicial Court this week that Plymouth Superior Court Judge William Sullivan should have done more to get a verdict and trying her again would constitute double jeopardy.

“Respectfully, contrary to the trial court’s stated belief at the time, it did have viable choices other than declaring a mistrial,” her attorneys Martin Weinberg, Kevin Reddington, and Michael Pabian wrote in their filing.

During the deliberations, the jury sent back two notes about the holdout, one of which said the juror “has made statements acknowledging doubt, but refuses to apply it to the verdict as the law states.”

The defense said this showed that the juror couldn’t follow the law or Sullivan’s instructions and asked for additional inquiry.

Sullivan individually asked all the jurors, under oath, if they could follow the law, and gave an additional reasonable doubt instruction, but he denied the defense’s request to look further into the holdout, later identified as Michael Desronvil.

“There is a substantial possibility that the trial court, after inquiry, would have discharged the non-compliant juror,” Clancy’s attorneys argued in the SJC filing. “Such possibility, therefore, constitutes a viable alternative to the mistrial, precluding a finding of manifest necessity.”

The defense moved to dismiss the case in state court on double jeopardy grounds, asking for an evidentiary hearing that took a closer look at Desronvil, but Sullivan denied both of those motions.

 

Plymouth Assistant District Attorney Melissa W. Johnsen submitted her opposition to Clancy’s petition Thursday.

“The Commonwealth submits that the Superior Court properly declared a mistrial due to manifest necessity after the jury had twice reported that it was deadlocked following due and thorough deliberation,” she wrote. “As such, double jeopardy does not operate to bar the Commonwealth from seeking justice on behalf of the three young victims.”

Johnsen argued the deliberation notes “suggested merely a disagreement amongst deliberating jurors, not dischargeable misconduct.”

Earlier this week, Clancy was back in state court to schedule her retrial for March.

Prosecutors hinted that she’ll face first-degree murder charges again, saying they’d need to arrange a jury trial. In Massachusetts, first-degree murder cases must be tried by a jury.

Reddington, who represented Clancy in the first proceedings, said that he’d likely use the same defense in the spring: he argued at trial that his client was suffering from postpartum psychosis when she killed the children and couldn’t be held criminally responsible.

Clancy’s next state court appearance is scheduled for Dec. 30.

_____


©2026 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit at bostonherald.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus