Current News

/

ArcaMax

NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani signs carriage horse ban, triggering TWU lawsuit

Evan Simko-Bednarski, New York Daily News on

Published in News & Features

NEW YORK — Mayor Zohran Mamdani Thursday signed into law a ban on horse-drawn carriage tours in New York City, triggering immediate legal action by the Transport Workers Union, which filed suit in Manhattan Federal Court minutes later.

“Since 1863, they have been a mainstay of Central Park, carrying New Yorkers and visitors on carriage rides for hire across the iconic landscape,” Mamdani said. “Our city has changed. And now it is time for our laws to change too.”

“As I sign this bill into law, I do so with a deep sense of both gratitude and obligation toward the more than 200 New Yorkers who make up the horse carriage industry today,” the mayor added. “I have the utmost respect for the work that carriage drivers and stable hands do.”

He added: “We understand the responsibility that we hold to facilitate a transition that is both fair and respectful to this industry.”

In one sense, Mamdani’s John Hancock put to rest a decades-long battle over the future of horse-drawn tours in the center of Manhattan, enacting a law that opponents of the industry have been fighting for decades just to bring to a vote. But in another, the suit and signing is only that battle’s latest salvo.

Romanch’s Law — named for the 18-year-old tourist who died while diving after his mother who was thrown from a carriage pulled by a spooked horse — became the law of the land Thursday morning.

Sovia Thukral — Romanch Mahajan’s aunt and an outspoken advocate for the law — was present for the bill signing, as was former mayor Bill de Blasio, whose multiple efforts to ban the industry failed during his administration.

“It is impossible to describe the pain that Romanch’s family has endured,” Mamdani said from the lectern Thursday. “No one should ever have to reckon with such suffering.”

Enacting a ban long sought by animal rights activists — who argue that having a horse pull a carriage through Gotham is inherently abusive — Romanch’s Law mandates the end of the carriage horse industry by summer 2028, and puts an immediate halt to the issuance of any new carriage horse licenses. It also forbids horse owners from selling their equines into carriage-horse use anywhere else.

The law was passed last months by a veto-proof majority of the City Council.

Romanch’s Law also requires the city to come up with a plan to assist the roughly 300-person strong workforce behind the carriage tours. Mamdani indicated earlier this week that he would push for the city to buy back the 68 horse-carriage medallions issued to owners — and worth roughly $400,000 a pop — as well as develop a job-training program for the industry’s drivers and stable hands.

But the powerful Transport Workers Union Local 100, which represents the carriage horse industry in addition to some 40,000 of the city’s subway and bus workers and has spent a tremendous amount of money and effort to fend off a horse-carriage ban, made good on its threat Thursday to sue the city “the minute the ink dries.”

“Despite the good intentions of the mayor, the protections he outlined recently should have been written into the legislation,” TWU international president John Samuelsen said in a statement Thursday.

 

“This bill is an unconstitutional abomination,” the union boss said. “It strips horse-carriage owners of the city-issued medallions that they purchased for hundreds of thousands of dollars — without mandating or guaranteeing compensation.”

“It prohibits carriage drivers from selling their horses to carriage-ride operators in another city, or even another state where rides are permitted. And that’s just the tip of the iceberg,” he added.

The suit — brought in the Southern District of New York by the TWU, two owners and one driver — argues that the law unfairly targets Central Park carriage horse tours while leaving in place other equine industries like horseback riding and racing, and does not explicitly offer “just compensation” to owners and drivers who were participating in a regulated and sanctioned city function.

“The City’s approach can be summarized in twelve words,” the suit reads, “immediately cripple the owners, ignore property interests and contracts, and maybe compensate.”

“We have 68 medallions here which cost people $300,000 or $400,000, which today the city made worth zero,” Arthur Schwartz, attorney for TWU, said Thursday. “We are talking about the taking of property without due process of law.”

“You don’t say, ‘we’re going to take your property, we’ll figure out how to deal with it later,'” Schwartz added. “You can’t do that, that’s not how our constitution works.”

The suit also argues that the carriage horses do not present a threat to public safety. Attorneys for the union point to reports of stray electrical voltage at the park — first reported by the Daily News — as a possible reason the horse that was carrying Romanch when he died bolted in the first place.

“(Romanch’s Law) does nothing about electrical hazards on City streets or banning the use of conductive materials as footing, which threaten NYPD mounted horses, horses working under special-event permits, pedestrians and animals alike,” the suit reads.

Regardless of the coming legal battle, animal rights activists heralded the law’s enactment Thursday.

“One hundred and sixty years ago, the mistreatment of a carriage horse inspired Henry Bergh to found the ASPCA, and protecting horses has been central to our mission ever since,” Matt Bershadker, president of The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, said in a statement. “Today’s signing of Romanch’s Law brings that commitment full circle.”

_____


©2026 New York Daily News. Visit nydailynews.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus