Current News

/

ArcaMax

Appeals court deals blow to Illinois in case over nonprofit DEI law

Olivia Olander, Chicago Tribune on

Published in News & Features

CHICAGO — A federal appeals court Wednesday revived a challenge by a conservative legal group and President Donald Trump’s administration to an Illinois law that requires large charitable nonprofits to publicly post demographic information about their board members and officers.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the 7th Circuit overturned a lower court’s decision to dismiss complaints brought by the group, the American Alliance for Equal Rights, and the Justice Department, sending the case back to the federal district judge in Chicago. The ruling was a setback for the state and the state’s advocacy for diversity, equity and inclusion initiatives, as the Trump administration over the past two years has tried to stamp out those efforts nationwide.

The 2024 law, which Gov. JB Pritzker signed, requires large nonprofit organizations that report issuing at least $1 million in charitable grants to post the “aggregated demographic information” about their directors and officers on their websites, including race, gender, disability status and sexual orientation. Board members are not compelled to answer those demographic questions.

That voluntary element was central to the state’s defense. Illinois argued the law did not compel anyone to disclose personal information. If board members don’t self-report, “then the statute does not require the organizations to post anything at all on their websites, and there is no injury to the anonymous organizations,” the state said in a filing.

But the appellate court disagreed. In its filing Wednesday, the appellate judges responded to the state’s argument, saying there was a “commonsense inference” that some board members and officers would likely fill out a demographic survey, even if others objected.

The court also agreed with the district court that the alliance’s member organizations could remain anonymous, another apparent win for the conservative group.

The American Alliance for Equal Rights — a Texas-based organization founded by an anti-affirmative action activist — sued Illinois officials, including Attorney General Kwame Raoul, over the law at the beginning of 2025, shortly after it took effect and Trump took office for his second term. Filing the suit on behalf of two unnamed groups subject to the law’s disclosure requirement, the organization said the measure violated constitutional rights to free speech and equal protection under the First and 14th amendments.

Requiring nonprofits to publish demographic data pressures organizations “to discriminate when choosing board members,” the group argued in a court filing. The federal Justice Department under then-U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi joined the case, too, echoing some of the plaintiff’s allegations and adding the state and Pritzker as defendants, according to a court filing.

A federal judge dismissed the Justice Department’s lawsuit and partially dismissed the American Alliance lawsuit more than a year ago. Both the organization and the federal government appealed, and a panel of judges heard arguments in the consolidated appeals in September.

The appellate court found the challengers had standing in the case, but it did not rule on the law’s constitutionality.

 

Following the appellate court ruling, Edward Blum, the conservative activist who leads the American Alliance, said in a message to the group’s members that the organization planned to continue its legal efforts to block the law.

“The constitutional questions remain open. What we won today is the right to have those questions litigated and to represent the two charities that stepped forward to challenge this law,” Blum wrote.

A spokesperson with the Department of Justice, Kiersten Pels, framed the ruling as confirmation “that the United States has standing to enforce its citizens’ Equal Protection rights, especially when clear statutory authority exists.”

Spokespeople for Pritzker and Raoul did not return requests for comment.

A Tribune investigation earlier this year found few of the state’s largest grantmaking foundations had published the required information on their websites as the law outlines. The investigation highlighted the law’s lack of enforcement mechanisms or penalties for noncompliance.

It was supposed to build on previous state efforts to make leadership diversity more transparent, including a more than decade-old law on reporting demographic information about state board appointees, and a six-year-old requirement that Illinois-based publicly traded companies report their board of directors demographics.

The Trump administration, which recently was dealt a major blow as voters in this month’s midterm elections chose to send a wave of new Democratic lawmakers to Congress, has made dismantling DEI programs that it sees as unfair or illegal a key part of its second-term agenda.

“Merit, Restored,” a header on the White House’s website reads. “President Trump promised it and delivered — DEI is dead.”

____


©2026 Chicago Tribune. Visit at chicagotribune.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus