Federal judge finds Colorado ICE agents violated court order in rearrest, but declines to impose more sanctions
Published in News & Features
DENVER — Immigration officials “were in clear contempt” of a federal court’s order when they rearrested a recently released immigrant detainee in Aurora last month, a judge ruled Wednesday.
“Sometimes, behavior stuns and renders a listener speechless,” U.S. District Court Judge Charlotte Sweeney wrote in her ruling, reacting to the officials’ conduct. “In one turn of phrase, lost for words.”
But Sweeney declined to impose any penalties on those officials, including a senior U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement official in Denver, because an ICE supervisor confirmed to her — nearly two weeks after the policy began in late October — that the agency had stopped rearresting people after the practice prompted criticism from judges and outcries from attorneys and the public.
During that time, at least 18 detainees — all of whom had been ordered released by Sweeney and other federal judges — were summarily rearrested as soon as they left the Aurora detention center.
One was nearly deported. Another previously told The Denver Post that he was violently arrested as soon as he walked out the detention center’s front door. All 18 detainees have since been released again.
In her Wednesday order, Sweeney criticized the “unconstitutional behavior that (ran) top to bottom” within the rearrest policy. When she learned earlier this month that a man that she’d ordered released had been immediately rearrested, Sweeney summoned attorneys from the Department of Justice and Nicole Black, a deputy supervisor with ICE’s Denver field office, to demand an explanation. She then held another hearing on Nov. 9 and said she was weighing whether to hold Black and other officials in contempt.
Sweeney’s contempt findings included Black and other respondents in the case, among them U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche and Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin. As is common in court cases, senior federal officials were included in the detained immigrant’s initial filing seeking release from the facility. The officials were then carried over into the rest of the proceedings after the man was rearrested.
Spokespeople for the Homeland Security Department did not immediately respond to a message seeking comment on the new ruling. Nor did Tim Macdonald, the legal director of the American Civil Liberties Union of Colorado, which had joined the case to highlight ICE’s conduct.
In court, Black said she was told to again detain people who’d been ordered released. Her supervisor, Nathan Rasper, said agents rearrested people to fix “technical” issues related to the detainees’ initial arrests.
Amid ICE’s record-setting arrests since President Donald Trump returned to office, hundreds of detainees have filed federal challenges to their detentions, often on the basis of their arrests or prolonged confinements. ICE has repeatedly been criticized by another federal judge in Colorado for illegally arresting people, and federal judges have ordered the release of many detainees in recent months.
Black testified that she believed the rearrests were legal.
On Wednesday, Sweeney dismissed that explanation as “ridiculous” and said it “should — and, in the court’s opinion, must — shock any reader.” She unequivocally found that Black had violated her order based on “a belief that necessarily depends on disregarding the fundamental way in which branches of government work.”
“There is not a single word in this Nation’s Constitution that sustains or could plausibly give rise to Ms. Black’s ‘belief’ that ICE and ICE agents can walk out to the sidewalk and reshackle a habeas petitioner within a minute of that petitioner’s court-ordered release,” Sweeney wrote.
During the Nov. 9 hearing, Rasper, ICE’s acting director in Denver, said he had come up with the idea after talking with other ICE officials. He said he had ordered the policy to stop after the outcry from Sweeney.
The cessation of the policy, Sweeney wrote, “essentially cured Ms. Black’s and (and other federal officials’) contempt.”
Sweeney’s order is not the first time a federal judge has criticized ICE officials for failing to follow court orders.
Twice this year, U.S. District Court Judge R. Brooke Jackson has found that ICE has continued to illegally arrest people without warrants in violation of both federal law and his orders. In late September, Jackson said agents involved in some of the arrests deserved to be sanctioned by the agency.
_____
©2026 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit at denverpost.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments