Current News

/

ArcaMax

City Council votes to turn off Flock and smart streetlight cameras in San Diego

Teri Figueroa, The San Diego Union-Tribune on

Published in News & Features

SAN DIEGO — San Diego’s police surveillance network is going dark.

The San Diego City Council on Monday rescinded its approval of police use of automated license plate readers, as well as the 500 so-called smart streetlight cameras that are placed throughout the city. The vote calls for an end to the $2 million annual agreement with Ubicquia, the company that provides the cameras, and Flock, the company that provides the plate-reader technology linked to the cameras.

While local privacy advocates have long pushed back against automated license plate readers, or ALPRs, resistance to them — and specifically against Flock, the largest provider in the market — swelled nationally over the last year. San Diego adds itself to a growing number of cities that are turning the cameras off.

Concern about government overreach — particularly amid the Trump administration’s immigration crackdown — and public mistrust of police use of the technology fueled the decision.

“We should not have to choose between public safety, civil liberties and the right to privacy,” Council member Henry Foster said. “San Diegans deserve them all.”

The council’s vote to turn off Flock was unanimous, with Council members Marni von Wilpert and Jennifer Campbell absent on Monday. And while Mayor Todd Gloria has supported the cameras, he said he would not veto the council vote. Even if he had, Monday’s 7-0 vote was a veto-proof supermajority.

The decision ends a three-year run of the ALPRs, which take pictures and record details, including plate number, make, model, color and distinguishing markings, on all vehicles that pass by, then store those details in a searchable database. San Diego police hold that data for 30 days unless it is used in an investigation. The technology captured about 4 million cars each month while it was turned on.

The vote to cut the contract comes about a month before the annual $2 million bill comes due for the next calendar year.

After the vote, San Diego Police Chief Scott Wahl issued a statement saying that he respects the council’s decision and that the department “will be working with the vendor to turn the system off in the next 24 hours.”

“Our officers and detectives will continue to provide the highest quality service when investigating crimes throughout our City,” Wahl said, in part.

Critics argue the technology is an affront to civil rights and say the data can be turned against drivers. Many fear federal officials could muscle access to the Flock data and use it to aid the Trump administration’s mass deportation agenda. Several council members cited community fears as the reason behind their decision to pull the plug.

“I see no path in preserving a law enforcement tool that wants to meet the needs of San Diegans and yet cannot address very real and very concerning issues,” said Council President Joe LaCava.

Council member Kent Lee pointed to “the increasing overreach that we’ve seen from our federal government, especially through the increased presence of Immigration and Customs Enforcement.”

“I do believe it is this time that we have to act,” Lee said. “I believe it’s time to prioritize the protection of civil rights and liberties for our residents.”

The vote was taken as part of the city’s annual review of surveillance technologies. In 2023, in response to previous strong pushback against surveillance technologies, the city passed an ordinance requiring the City Council to review — with an eye toward civil rights — all surveillance the city uses each year.

Until earlier this year, Lee had supported the ALPRs. So, too, had Council member Stephan Whitburn until calling to shutter them last month. On Monday, he acknowledged that ALPRs have solved crimes.

“My view of the effectiveness of ALPRs hasn’t changed. What has changed is the context,” Whitburn said, noting the election of Trump and the immigration focus. “The two years since have been a living hell for too many families in our city.”

Whitburn said that turning off the cameras means “giving up one crime-fighting tool. But our city is hardly without tools to fight crime. The city’s Flock cameras have been up for less than three years. San Diego has been one of the safest cities in America for decades.”

 

Last December, von Wilpert voted to keep the cameras, but last week said she would support shutting them off. She reiterated that position Monday in a statement explaining that she was absent to attend mandatory training for her role as a newly elected member of Congress. Campbell was also absent during the vote in December 2025.

It’s a defeat for the San Diego Police Department, which runs the ALPR program and has fought to keep it alive, arguing it is a force multiplier and crime-solving tool. Wahl has argued that his department follows the city’s strict rules, including keeping its data on a metaphorical island inaccessible to other agencies. San Diego police said Monday the city has seen a 20% drop in vehicle theft since 2023, and 689 stolen vehicles have been recovered using the tech.

LaCava said it is laudable that crimes have been solved and noted there have been a number of improvements in the department’s operation of ALPRs.

“Perhaps we indeed have the most secure operation anywhere in the country and best security of the data, but frankly, the best in the nation is not always good enough, especially when the climate of our nation is full of cruelty, danger and fear,” LaCava said.

The vote to get rid of the city’s smart streetlight cameras was mixed, 5-2, with Council members Raul Campillo and Vivian Moreno opting against pulling the plug. Without Flock, the cameras operate as normal surveillance cameras. The images from the Ubicquia cameras are kept for 13 days and are not run through AI to create a searchable database.

Both council members argued the surveillance cameras on their own can still be powerful crime-fighting tools, without being connected to an AI database.

However, Council member Sean Elo-Rivera said he felt the conversation about the smart streetlight program was similar to the one about Flock.

“My vote in support of this motion is not a vote in my inability to see the potential benefits of having cameras in the community,” Elo-Rivera said. “It’s my inability to tell the community that I’m fully confident that their privacy will be respected, and the technology will be properly used in a way that I can assure them.”

After the vote, Gloria issued a statement that ALPRs and the streetlight cameras “provided our police officers with the ability to efficiently and effectively investigate serious crimes, but public trust is essential for their continued use.”

Scores of people spoke during the more than two hours of public comment at Monday’s meeting, with nearly all of them asking to kill ALPRs. Some speakers brought a theatrical flair to the proceedings — one dressed as a Flock camera, another as Princess Leia from “Star Wars,” and still another wore a fuzzy blue monster suit head to toe. One costumed speaker went by “Count Flockula,” another dressed as a “Star Wars” rebel pilot and called himself “Luke Skydeflocker.”

One speaker wondered aloud: “I’m not sure if this is Comic-Con or a freaking City Council meeting.”

Some speakers, although far fewer, supported keeping the ALPR technology. Another 14 people present submitted forms indicating support but declined to address the council.

The pushback against the cameras has recently landed the city in court. In September, a local civil rights advocacy group sued San Diego, alleging the cameras and the database they create amount to an invasion of privacy under the state constitution. The city is also facing a federal lawsuit from a man who alleges he was wrongfully jailed for a month after police using ALPRs targeted the wrong vehicle.

_____

Staff writer Caleb Lunetta contributed to this report.

_____


©2026 The San Diego Union-Tribune. Visit sandiegouniontribune.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus