Prosecutors say they lack evidence of bias motive in Uber assault
Published in News & Features
MINNEAPOLIS — A man was charged Tuesday with severely injuring his Somali American Uber driver in an attack over the weekend that the victims’ supporters contend was a hate crime based on his ethnicity.
Samit Apurva Patel, 25, of Hopkins, was charged in Hennepin County District Court with second-degree attempted murder and first-degree carjacking.
The driver, 51-year-old Mohamed Yusuf, of Blaine, remains in critical condition at HCMC, a hospital spokesperson said.
The criminal complaint did not address whether ethnic bias was a motive, beyond Patel allegedly expressing he did not like Yusuf’s name, and County Attorney Mary Moriarty said her office does not have the evidence to “prove beyond a reasonable doubt that this assault was motivated by bias.”
Minnesota does not have a specific hate or bias law, but the state uses the presence of hate or bias in a crime as an enhancement in determining the severity of sentencing. Charges for crimes inspired by hate or bias can also be charged federally. The Minnesota Star Tribune inquired with the FBI about whether it is investigating this case, and a spokesman declined to comment.
Patel was arrested soon after the attack and appeared in court Tuesday afternoon, showed no emotion during the hearing and did not speak on the record. Two family members attended.
Meanwhile, Yusuf “continues to fight for his life, but his prognosis is poor,” the charges read.
Judge Paul Scoggin set bail at $800,000, the amount recommended by the prosecution, and called the allegations “quite chilling and surprising,” given the circumstances of the attack and Patel’s lack of a criminal record. Patel is due back in court on Dec. 16.
Defense attorney Michael Holland pushed for bail to be set at no more than $20,000. Among other reasons, he cited Patel’s clean criminal background, his college degree and employment in the real estate industry.
Moriarty pointed during a news conference Tuesday afternoon that “the environment for our Somali neighbors in our state is absolutely frightening. And it is worsened due to the comments made by the president … and many voices in this state.”
She acknowledged that her office has no indication that Patel was aware of the negative comments from public figures about Somalis, but “I don’t know how you can miss it. I can’t look at my social media ... I can’t watch the [news] media without seeing that it’s Somali fraud” or some other trouble assigned to that community as a whole.
Moriarty said no federal authorities have reached out to her office about the case, adding, “Do I expect to hear from the [Trump] administration? No.”
According to the criminal complaint, Patel’s parents called police about 1:20 a.m. and told them their son came home drunk and appeared confused, distressed and belligerent. They said Patel was “expressing fear regarding a strange vehicle that was parked outside the house in the middle of the street.”
Officers arrived at the home and saw an unoccupied SUV in the street with the engine running, the complaint read. The vehicle had significant damage, and vegetation was stuck to its underside.
Police spoke with Patel in the home, where he appeared intoxicated and difficult to understand, the complaint continued. He asked the officers to arrest him because he had done something bad.
Patel said he was out drinking with friends for a birthday party, and added, “I am taking responsibility for it,” the complaint quoted him as saying.
GPS data acquired by police from Uber showed that Yusuf picked up Patel at the Moose Bar and Grill in northeast Minneapolis, the charges said.
Officers found Yusuf’s phone inside the SUV and saw a call was still connected, with the driver’s brother on the other end, the charges read. The brother said he and Yusuf are both Uber drivers, and they often talk while driving.
According to the complaint, the brother told police he heard Patel ask Yusuf, “’What’s my name?’” Patel said it was Sam. Yusuf said his name was Mohamed.
Patel responded with a vulgarity-punctuated, “‘I don’t like that name,’” the charges continued.
The brother said he heard Patel and Yusuf arguing about where they were going before Yusuf was screaming in Somali that his passenger was going to kill him.
Yusuf said he was being choked with a belt, and then was heard by the brother to say, " ‘He was driving the car on top of me. He was running me over,’ " the complaint added.
Police used Yusuf’s smart watch to find him near Hopkins Crossroad and Minnetonka Boulevard in a ditch about 15 feet off the side of the road, the charges read.
Yusuf was taken to HCMC with broken ribs, a broken leg, spinal injuries, collapsed lungs and internal bleeding, the complaint noted.
Fartuun Mohamed, a niece of the driver Mohamed Yusuf, was one of many on Monday who said they were frightened and outraged by the assault. “My uncle should be at home today, not fighting for his life in critical condition,” she said.
More than 100 people attended a news conference Monday hosted by the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR MN) outside the emergency care building for HCMC, where family members say Yusuf has undergone multiple surgeries.
Speakers called for a thorough investigation into whether Patel targeted Yusuf because of his religion or race.
Hopkins police said Monday they have yet to determine whether ethnic bias was a factor in the reported attack, but “investigators are examining all available evidence and considering all potential motives,” Police Chief Brent Johnson said in a statement. “Our responsibility is to follow the evidence, establish the facts and ensure that any criminal charges are supported by the investigation.”
©2026 The Minnesota Star Tribune. Visit at startribune.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments