Current News

/

ArcaMax

Pakistani man who plotted to kill Trump for Iran gets 27 years for botched scheme

John Annese, New York Daily News on

Published in News & Features

NEW YORK — A bungling Pakistani businessman who thought two undercover FBI agents were hitmen he could hire to kill President Donald Trump on behalf of Iran got 27 and a half years behind bars in Brooklyn Federal Court Wednesday.

Asif Merchant, 48, who was recruited to become an operative of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, or IRGC, was busted in July 2024 after coming to the U.S. to set up a political assassination at a campaign rally. He was convicted at trial in March.

U.S. District Court Judge Eric Komitee, a Trump appointee, described the plot as “exceptionally serious” but decided Wednesday that federal prosecutors’ request Merchant get life in prison plus 10 years was “higher than necessary.”

“This was an exceptionally serious crime, an extreme instance of terroristic violence,” Komitee said. “No crimes … are more serious than the contemplated, targeted killing of a United States president or other government officials.”

Still, Komitee pointed out, the plot never got past its infancy, and the end result matters in sentencing. He brought up the example of two different drunken drivers, who both consume the same amount of alcohol, but one makes it home and the other kills someone.

“I think most people would agree that those two sentences would come out differently,” he said. Also, the judge said, Merchant has no criminal record, and when he was arrested, rather than show defiance like other terrorism suspects, he told authorities he made a mistake and that his family members had nothing to do with his actions.

Prosecutors presented Merchant as an Iranian intelligence operative looking to enact bloody revenge on Trump for the 2020 U.S. drone strike killing of one of the regime’s generals, Qasem Soleimani.

After Soleimani’s death, Merchant shared a meme on Facebook showing Trump’s severed head, with the blood-spattered words, “Coming soon,” written underneath, and another meme of Trump digging his own grave.

“The defendant believed that the ultimate target of his murder plot would be then-candidate, now President, Donald J. Trump, but stated that other targets could have been then-President Joe Biden and former United Nations Ambassador Nikki Haley, all of whom were United States presidential candidates at the time,” prosecutors wrote in a court filing earlier this month.

Merchant’s plot was dead on arrival, though — the man who he asked to help him find contract killers was actually a federal informant, and the two so-called Mafia hitmen he met at a strip club were actually undercover feds. He faces a possible life sentence.

Jurors in March heard from Merchant’s initial contact in New York, a member of the Pakistani community with deep ties to the U.S. government through his translation work for the military in Afghanistan.

Taking the stand under the assumed name Nadeem Ali, the man testified that he and Merchant had been acquainted for years, and when Merchant asked him to help find criminals to hire, he instead steered Merchant toward two FBI agents.

Merchant was caught on hidden video in a hotel room on June 4, using an unfolded napkin on a table to map out the assassination and describe it to Ali, putting down a creamsicle-colored vape as he said, “This is the target. How will it die?”

And his conversations with the undercover feds, who he paid $5,000, were caught on tape.

 

Merchant’s lawyers argued in a sentencing memo last month that the sloppiness of the plot undercuts the argument that he was a determined Iranian operative hell-bent on assassination.

“Although the charges for which Asif Merchant was found guilty are serious, this is an unusual case where the plot underlying those charges was so poorly conceived and executed, it neither could nor was intended to succeed,” they wrote. “Indeed, the government’s own evidence sounds more like the plot of an Inspector Clouseau movie than James Bond,” they said, referring to the clumsy detective in the “Pink Panther” films.

Merchant took the stand in his own defense, saying that his Iranian handler insinuated that Merchant’s wife and child in Iran would be harmed if he didn’t go through with the plot, and that he fully expected to be arrested at some point.

His lawyers doubled down on that argument in their sentencing letter, contending that Iranian intelligence used the defendant to serve a larger political goal if the plot fell through, as expected.

“In that respect, Mr. Merchant was a disposable dupe, used by the IRGC to wreak havoc on the American political system during an election year, with no expectation that the ill-conceived and executed plot would succeed,” his defense team wrote.

Prosecutors countered in their own letter to the judge that playing up the ineptitude of the plot was strategic.

“The defendant’s attempt to downplay the seriousness of his offense by comparing his terrorist plot to an Inspector Clouseau movie… is precisely the response that the IRGC hopes to achieve when risky external lethal operations go awry,” prosecutors wrote.

“Today’s sentence ensures that Asif Merchant never again has the opportunity to plan an evil attack on America,” U.S. Attorney Joseph Nocella said Tuesday. “Iran, its proxies and its terrorist assets near and far should recognize this case as an example of U.S. law enforcement’s strength. If you plan an attack on our democracy, on our elected officials, on our people, we will stop you and prosecute you to the fullest extent of the law.”

After the sentencing, Merchant’s lawyer Avi Moskovitz said he was disappointed by the verdict and the sentence, and will appeal, but was glad the judge took a thoughtful approach.

“We are grateful that the judge considered the arguments… and did not impose the draconian sentence by the government,” he said.

As for Komitee being a Trump appointee, Mokovitz said, “I think what is shows is that our judiciary remains independent, thankfully.”

_____


©2026 New York Daily News. Visit nydailynews.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus