Current News

/

ArcaMax

Sheng Thao trial: Former top city official takes the stand

Jakob Rodgers, The Mercury News on

Published in News & Features

OAKLAND, Calif. — The trial of ex-Oakland Mayor Sheng Thao transitioned into a new phase Monday, as a star witness for the prosecution wrapped up more than 30 hours of testimony and federal prosecutors homed in on a narrow — if key — element of the sprawling bribery scheme at the heart of their case.

Mario Juarez — the longtime political operator-turned-government cooperator — concluded his eighth day of testimony Monday in the trial of Thao, her romantic partner Andre Jones and the father-son business duo of David and Andy Duong. Federal prosecutors then moved on to their first new witness in more than two and a half weeks, a former city official who spent six weeks as the city’s top employee in early 2023.

Thao and her three co-defendants are accused of partnering with Juarez on an illicit gambit to funnel thousands of dollars in bribes to Jones in exchange for broad influence within City Hall for the Duong family. That alleged access included promises of hand-picked appointments directed by the family, along with millions of dollars in new and renewed city contracts for companies owned by the Duongs and Juarez. All four co-defendants have pleaded not guilty.

Here’s the latest developments on the case:

Who testified on Monday?

Juarez ended his marathon run as the government’s star witness in the trial, capping testimony that dated back to Oct. 30. He previously pleaded guilty to a conspiracy charge in exchange for his testimony in the case; he faces up to five years in prison at a future sentencing hearing.

Harold Duffey, who previously served as an interim city administrator during Thao’s earliest days as mayor, took the stand for the remainder of the day.

A surprise response to a promotion

Federal prosecutors on Monday shifted their focus to a key element of the ex-mayor’s alleged bribery scheme — the hand-picked hire of longtime city staffer Larry Gallegos in March 2023 to a key post within the city’s housing department.

Prosecutors previously elicited testimony that Juarez and the Duongs originally wanted Gallegos — then a program manager with the city’s Economic & Workforce Development Department — to be appointed as a city administrator or a department director. Juarez said he and the Duongs had sought the appointment while pursuing a multimillion-dollar contract with the city of Oakland to supply it with hundreds of housing units from their fledgling company, Evolutionary Homes.

Yet that alleged plan never quite came to fruition, according to court testimony.

On Monday, Duffey testified that Gallegos represented the lone person whom Thao personally recommended for a director-level position within the city — in this case, the head of the Economic & Workforce Development Department.

Feeling that Gallegos was unqualified for the position, Duffey said he instead opted to slide the longtime staffer into the role of interim deputy director of the Department of Housing and Community Development. Duffey said he did so without personally interviewing Gallegos — or without interviewing or even considering anyone else for the role — as a way to “honor” Thao’s request for Gallegos to join her team.

“The mayor wanted Larry to join her team — she made that very clear to me,” Duffey testified.

Offering Gallegos the deputy-director position represented a middle-ground approach, Duffey said, by ensuring Gallegos ended up in a position for which he was better qualified.

The move didn’t go over too smoothly, Duffey testified.

Duffey recalled Gallegos being “surprised” about the promotion. Instead of reacting with excitement, Gallegos “wasn’t happy with the results,” and allegedly told Duffey he wanted to double-check with Thao before accepting the position.

On cross-examination, Duffey acknowledged that Thao never pressured him to hire Gallegos as the city’s housing director, nor did Thao ever suggest that Gallegos would be hired as the city’s permanent city administrator.

 

Duffey also said Thao never pressed him to pursue a city contract with the Duongs’ housing company.

The move proved short-lived. While Gallegos eventually accepted the job change, he returned to his old role with the city’s Economic and Workforce Development Department by late 2023.

After less than two months as interim city administrator, Duffey became an assistant city administrator for the remainder of Thao’s term. He left the city in September 2025 to become city manager in Brentwood; he resigned a year later amid scrutiny over sexually suggestive text messages he exchanged while working in Oakland, as well as allegations about his treatment of women in Brentwood City Hall.

Down another juror

The ranks of jurors available to hear the case is increasingly thin.

Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers announced the dismissal of yet another juror Monday, marking the third person excused since the jury was empaneled on Oct. 12. Gonzalez Rogers — as has been her custom throughout the trial — offered no explanation for why the most recent juror was excused.

The move leaves just three alternate jurors available to step in, should one of the 12 primary jurors hearing the case have to leave for one reason or another. That’s a mounting concern for Gonzalez Rogers, given the plodding pace of testimony and the increasing likelihood that the case will extend far longer than was originally planned.

Prosecutors originally said their case would take three to four weeks to present their case, and defense attorneys initially estimated taking a week or two to call their own witnesses. As a result, Gonzalez Rogers told prospective jurors back in mid-October that they’d likely be finished by Thanksgiving.

That’s since changed. Gonzalez Rogers informed the jury last week that testimony from both sides was expected to continue through the first part of December, with deliberations likely starting around Dec. 10. That assumes no more delays in a case that has seen cross-examinations extend far longer than expected.

A mistrial would likely result if four more jurors are dismissed for any reason.

On Monday, Gonzalez Rogers offered a lighthearted — if earnest — plea for the jury to persevere until the case concludes.

“OK, that’s it, no one else can have a problem,” the judge said. “It’s making me really nervous.”

The judge has had her own hardships arise during the trial. On Nov. 9, Gonzalez Rogers announced she had broken her right arm during a bike ride the previous weekend. Testimony began about 90 minutes late one morning while she consulted with a surgeon about the injury, though it does not appear she will have to miss any more time for further medical appointments.

What’s next

Cross-examination of Duffey is expected to resume when court reconvenes at 8:30 a.m. Tuesday.

_____


©2026 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit at mercurynews.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus