California's reproductive privacy law has its first case: a woman investigated after stillbirth
Published in News & Features
A woman is suing the city of Los Angeles as well as detectives within the Los Angeles Police Department for allegedly unlawful interrogation and investigation following a stillbirth she had in 2024 — two years after California authorized the right for patients to sue for being investigated due to their pregnancy outcomes.
This is the first known lawsuit under the state’s Reproductive Privacy Act, which was amended in 2022 to prohibit the state from taking punitive action based on pregnancy decisions and outcomes. California’s strong right-to-sue protections could become a legal roadmap for other states, said Sara Ainsworth, one of the attorneys representing the plaintiff, who was granted anonymity Thursday and is referred to in the complaint as Jane Doe.
The plaintiff alleges that in November 2024 she was unhoused, living in a city shelter and menstruating irregularly due to her epilepsy medication. An emergency visit for stomach pains revealed she was pregnant, but the fetus did not have a heartbeat. According to the complaint, Doe was initially informed she was still in the first trimester and could miscarry at home but subsequently learned she was around 29 weeks’ pregnant.
She passed significant blood clots in the shelter toilet, left without flushing and was taken by ambulance to the hospital and treated for significant blood loss, the complaint says, also noting that Doe didn’t realize she had passed the stillbirth.
According to the complaint, police showed up at the hospital, shackled her to a bed and interrogated her for hours, telling her that a fetus had been found outside the shelter.
“This was the first time Ms. Doe learned that she had passed into the toilet. And it was the first time she heard that someone had reportedly moved the fetus from the toilet to an alley outside the shelter,” the complaint said.
The complaint alleges police continued to pursue a homicide investigation for about a year despite being told by a medical examiner that fetal demise had occurred in utero.
The Los Angeles Police Department declined to comment citing the pending litigation.
“All the different things that they did to Ms. Doe are a violation of the Reproductive Privacy Act,” said Ainsworth, chief legal and policy director at pregnancy-rights nonprofit If/When/How, which helped California pass the right-to-sue law and filed the complaint this month alongside law firm BraunHagey & Borden LLP.
“It’s very important to show the state actors in California that they must abide by the law, which prohibits criminalizing somebody,” Ainsworth said.
At least 13 states and the District of Columbia have in recent years enacted measures to ensure protections for people’s pregnancy decisions and outcomes, including California, Colorado, Hawaii, Illinois, Michigan, Missouri, Montana, New Mexico, Ohio, Oregon, Vermont, Virginia and Washington.
But among the few other places that explicitly allow damages suits — including D.C., Colorado and Illinois — California is the only state to eliminate common legal immunities for law enforcement, Ainsworth said.
Women in other states have sued for facing criminal charges after a pregnancy loss, including Brittany Watts in Ohio, who last year sued the city of Warren, city policy officers and a hospital after she was arrested and charged with abuse of a corpse following a miscarriage in her home.
But Ainsworth noted that in other states it can be harder to determine who’s accountable.
“It is typically hard, unfortunately, to hold government officials accountable for wrongful criminalization because of legal barriers,” she said. “The Reproductive Privacy Act in California explicitly not only allows a private right of action but eliminates some of those immunities, allowing government actors who normally are shielded to actually be held accountable for their actions.”
In the first three years after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in 2022, more than 900 women faced criminal charges for conduct related to their pregnancies. The vast majority of the charges were for child abuse, neglect or endangerment, most related to substance use during pregnancy. But some involved allegations related to failing to obtain prenatal care or other actions taken or not taken during pregnancy or after pregnancy loss.
In California, Doe alleges she had to leave the shelter after police told reporters they suspected a homicide and headlines circulated about a newborn baby dropped from a fourth-floor window.
In February 2025, she contacted a legal helpline run by If/When/How, and started working with litigation counsel Shantal McNeil, who helped Doe navigate the investigation and petitioned the city attorney not to bring charges.
McNeil said reputational damage and other harms often outlast these types of arrests and investigations, even when charges are dropped or never filed. She said police often investigate vulnerable women like the California plaintiff, who according to her attorneys, is a young woman.
“People mistakenly think that every pregnancy ends in a healthy baby, or that if this circumstance would happen to them, they would respond differently. … So, if you don’t act in the way that (police) think you should, it’s suddenly suspicious or criminal behavior,” McNeil said. “To us, this is what the hospital told her, ‘Go home, you’re having a miscarriage.’ So the fact that any of this happened because of that or after that is quite mind boggling.”
____
Stateline reporter Sofia Resnick can be reached at sresnick@stateline.org.
____
©2026 States Newsroom. Visit at stateline.org. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.






Comments