Current News

/

ArcaMax

Jury begins deliberations in retrial of man charged with causing devastating Palisades fire in early 2025

Sierra van der Brug, Los Angeles Daily News on

Published in News & Features

LOS ANGELES — Months after jurors deadlocked in the arson trial of a 30-year-old former Uber driver accused of causing the devastating Palisades fire, a newly chosen jury began deliberations Wednesday in his retrial on fewer charges.

The jury of six men and six women is tasked with deciding if Jonathan Rinderknecht, a onetime Pacific Palisades resident, is responsible for the New Year’s Eve blaze that smoldered and soon rekindled into the Palisades fire in early 2025, or if the blaze could have been sparked by a firework or cigarette. Attorneys for both sides presented closing arguments to the panel on Wednesday afternoon.

Rinderknecht is charged with two arson-related counts, destruction of property by means of fire and arson affecting property used in interstate commerce. He has pleaded not guilty. The charges stem from the Jan. 1, 2025 Lachman fire, which burned 8 to 10 acres. Authorities say that fire became a holdover fire and continued to smolder underground in root systems for several days, before high winds caused it to reignite on Jan. 7, 2025, when it became the Palisades fire, which went on to burn over 23,500 acres and kill 12 people.

A charge of timber set afire he faced during his initial June trial has since been dropped. In June, jurors deadlocked, a mistrial was declared and the government quickly vowed to try him again. Jurors revealed the panel had been split 10 to two, with 10 jurors in favor of a not guilty verdict and two in favor of a guilty verdict.

Following roughly two weeks of testimony, including Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives agents, witnesses in the Palisades on Dec. 31, behavioral analysts and Uber passengers, the case was handed to the jury on Wednesday.

Part of the jury instructions given by U.S. District Judge Anne Hwang required the jury to not consider whether the Los Angeles Fire Department adequately put out the Lachman or Palisades fires in their decision. Hwang also ordered no references to the first trial could be made during the retrial.

Prosecutors argued Rinderknecht was the sole person on Hidden Buddha Hill, where the fire began that night, by his own admission and evidenced by photos and videos of the hillside, where he went after driving Uber passengers. He had lived in the Pacific Palisades years prior and was familiar with the lookout point and hiking trail.

They argued that, fresh off of rejection from a girlfriend and a former partner, he lit a fire with an open flame, which they say is proven by evidence collected and analyzed by certified fire investigators, federal agents and investigators.

In closing arguments, prosecutors focused less on the Palisades fire than during the first trial, instead honing in on the Lachman fire, highlighting how that fire alone damaged public lands. Prosecutors also placed less emphasis on Rinderknecht’s affect and personality and disdain for the wealthy in their retrial closings.

“He tried to call his former partner but there was no answer. The night before, he blew up at his girlfriend … hours before … he was angry and frustrated,” Assistant U.S. Attorney Mark Williams said.

It was in that state of mind, prosecutors argued, that Rinderknecht walked around Hidden Buddha Hill on the clear New Year’s Eve night, lit a fire using a bright green, long-handled lighter, and then tried to create an alibi.

 

Prosecutors said the defendant called 911 several times and screen-recorded himself doing so, as well as screen-recording himself asking ChatGPT “Are you at fault if a fire is lift [sic] because of your cigarettes.” This was something, prosecutors argued, he would not do if he had nothing to do with the fire, or if it had been started by a firework, which prosecutors said was ruled out as a cause by investigators. Prosecutors also said cigarettes were ruled out as a potential cause through hundreds of tests by investigators at a fire research lab.

“You witnessed how one person’s bad decision and anger could lead to this,” Williams told the jury, gesturing to photos of the Palisades fire’s devastation.

Defense attorney Steve Haney emphasized the separation between evidence of arson and what he calls evidence of “the man,” such as Rinderknecht’s messages, private thoughts and what his Uber passengers thought of him, suggesting that the prosecution’s case focused on the latter.

“The verdict form will not ask you whether you like Jonathan Rinderknecht,” Haney said.

Haney argued that prosecutors and investigators “decided, charged and tested” the case, in that order, deciding the cause of the fire in August 2025, arresting Rinderknecht in October 2025 and then doing ignition tests of the lighter in July 2026.

The lighter tests were conducted after Rinderknecht’s June trial and were presented to a jury for the first time during the retrial. Prosecutors said that investigators “cognitively tested” the idea that the fire was caused by an open flame before physical tests were done, determining that fireworks, cigarettes, refraction, lightning and electrical and power lines were all ruled out as causes.

Haney said Rinderknecht’s ownership of the lighter explains his DNA presence, but maintained that prosecutors never sufficiently proved that his client started the fire with the lighter – there are no videos of or witnesses to the moment the fire started.

“I can guarantee your DNA is on the lighter in your kitchen drawer,” Haney said.

Haney referenced witnesses who testified hearing and seeing fireworks in the area on New Year’s Eve, suggesting fireworks could have caused the blaze, the Lachman fire scene remaining open to the public for several days, during which he argued evidence could have been lost or destroyed. Investigators obtained records from AT&T and T-Mobile, but Verizon’s records had been deleted by that point, which means anyone who got phone service from that provider could have been on the hill and no one will ever know, adding to reasonable doubt, Haney argued.

_____


©2026 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit dailynews.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus