A court ordered ICE to stop its detention policy. Here's what changed in Idaho
Published in News & Features
BOISE, Idaho — An appeals court this summer rejected the Trump administration’s expansion of mandatory detention, which left many immigrants detained without a bond hearing.
But new numbers show Immigration and Customs Enforcement, when determining whether to keep Idaho immigrants in custody, is releasing very few people.
After the July appeals court ruling, agents had taken 260 people into custody in Idaho through the first part of October. But after determining whether to keep them detained, they only released three people — a release rate of just over 1%, U.S. District Court Judge B. Lynn Winmill of Idaho wrote in recent court documents, adding that the “statistical evidence raises some concerns.”
It’s unclear why those three were released. ICE also said it had “pursued non-custodial enforcement alternatives” at least 15 times since the July ruling, but it is unclear what that means. ICE did not respond to a message seeking comment.
“Such a low release rate raises questions about whether ICE is genuinely exercising its discretionary authority or instead continuing, in practice, to apply a presumption of detention so strongly that release is rarely a meaningful possibility,” Winmill wrote in an Oct. 30 ruling on the Idaho case of a Mexican man who entered the U.S. in the early 2020s.
The man, who said he was married to a U.S. citizen, faced arrest in a 2024 Canyon County case (though the charge was dismissed) and then again in a 2026 Ada County case, this time for allegedly driving without privileges, court documents said.
ICE took the man into custody in August, right after the appeals court ruling.
In Idaho and elsewhere, immigrants had filed “a flood” of legal procedures challenging their detention, disputing a Trump administration policy that left many people detained without a bond hearing. In July, the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled the policy must stop. Instead of detaining some immigrants under the mandatory detention section of code, agents needed to use another, under which they decide on a case-by-case basis whether to keep someone detained.
In the Mexican man’s case, ICE determined he was a flight risk and kept him in custody, court documents said. He was transferred to a jail in Weiser. But the man’s lawyers argued that ICE hadn’t released anyone on bond in Idaho since that court decision in July. They said ICE didn’t actually make a personalized determination about whether he was a flight risk and that the man was kept in custody “pursuant to a blanket policy.”
Ultimately, Winmill denied the man’s request for release. Some of what ICE considered in deciding the man was a flight risk was “debatable,” Winmill wrote, but the question wasn’t whether he would have reached the same conclusion. Instead, Winmill said, ICE did in fact exercise discretion.
After the initial ICE determination, immigrants can go in front of an immigration judge to seek release. However, Idaho lawyers previously raised concerns about such hearings — such as in Tacoma, Washington, where many Idaho immigrants go for proceedings. In fiscal year 2023, Tacoma immigration judges granted bond in 3% of cases in fiscal year 2023, the lowest bond rate in the U.S., according to a court document. Winmill himself previously released an immigrant whose Tacoma bond hearing he called “fundamentally unfair,” after the judge used evidence that wasn’t in the record.
Winmill understood the Mexican man’s concerns about a potential bond hearing in Tacoma, he wrote in his order. But despite fairness and efficacy concerns, Winmill didn’t want to presume what would happen before any hearing took place. Winmill ordered the man to receive a bond hearing within seven days, if the man hadn’t already received one.
The detentions are part of a Trump administration crackdown on immigration. There isn’t an easy legal path right now to challenge them, said Chris Christensen, a Boise-based immigration lawyer.
Christensen said the administration was using a carrot (the Trump administration’s self-deportation plan includes offering money for people to voluntarily leave) and stick (locking people up with no bond) strategy “extremely effectively.”
“It is extremely uphill to get out of detention,” Christensen said. “Because the government is using detention to break people down.”
_____
©2026 Idaho Statesman. Visit at idahostatesman.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments