Sports

/

ArcaMax

John Romano: This is not what the Buccaneers, or anyone, expected from Baker Mayfield

John Romano, Tampa Bay Times on

Published in Football

TAMPA, Fla. — When the season began, we were looking for doubt in all the wrong places.

We worried about the new faces on defense, we wondered about health on the offensive line, we fretted about details no sane person could imagine.

The one thing we didn’t worry about?

A world where Baker Mayfield might be the problem.

With Mike Evans moving on and Lavonte David retiring, this was unquestionably Mayfield’s team. His heart beat louder than any other, and his annual salary went far beyond anyone who ever played in Tampa Bay. Maybe Mayfield wobbled at the end of 2025, but that was easily dismissed as the result of too many aches and pains.

Even if you believed Mayfield was too erratic to be considered a franchise quarterback, he was still the guy who carried the Bucs to back-to-back division titles in 2023-24 and orchestrated four fourth-quarter comebacks in the first five weeks of last season.

So how did we end up here?

Nine weeks into a season with a 3-6 record and the most anemic passing attack in the NFL. And the guy who took pride in ignoring injuries while making 54 consecutive starts has already missed three games with a dislocated thumb and might not make it to the huddle on Sunday in Detroit because of a foot injury.

It’s not fair to load all the offense’s struggles on Mayfield’s plate, but he deserves a sizable portion of the blame. He’s throwing more interceptions and less touchdowns. He’s getting sacked way too much, and his passer rating is the worst in the NFC.

Yes, he misses Evans. Yes, new offensive coordinator Zac Robinson has not dazzled anyone with this playbook. Yes, the passing game has been deemphasized because the Bucs have been running the ball so well.

But there is no scenario where the Bucs make the playoffs without Mayfield playing dramatically better.

That’s just reality. Even a team that relies as heavily on the ground attack as Tampa Bay needs a legitimate passing game. It needs to keep defenses from stacking the line of scrimmage. It needs to make quick strikes at the end of the first half or the final two minutes of a game. It needs diversity.

 

Nothing wrong with having a strong running game, but this isn’t the 1970s. There’s a reason no Super Bowl winner has had more rushing than passing yards in the last 50 years or so.

“It’s been a little bit of a challenge lately,” head coach Todd Bowles said about the passing game last week. “We’ve got to make some changes.”

Bowles did not exactly absolve Robinson when asked about the passing game struggles. There seems to be a disconnect between what Robinson wants to do and what Mayfield and the rest of the offense is comfortable doing. If that’s the issue, it’s bizarre that it wasn’t recognized sooner, but at least it seems fixable.

The unspoken fear — the greater fear — is that there is something else at play.

One of Mayfield’s greatest strengths as a quarterback has been his relentless approach. He runs, he jumps, he jukes, he blocks, he bleeds. He has always been willing to sacrifice his body for an extra yard or two. It’s endearing to fans who paid big bucks to sit in the stadium’s lower bowl, but it’s reckless for long-term health.

Those cuts, dings and bruises can have a cumulative effect. And now that Mayfield is 31 with nine years of NFL wear and tear on his body, there’s bound to be residual issues. We saw it last season when Mayfield had 16 touchdown passes with two interceptions in the first nine games of the season, and then had 10 TDs and nine interceptions in the next eight games.

What we’ve seen thus far in 2026 is a continuation of the end of last season. The idea that Mayfield’s numbers are only marginally better — and in some cases a little worse — than what rookie Jalon Daniels did in his three starts is fairly concerning.

The hope is that this is a blip. A confluence of injuries, a new offensive system and the loss of Evans. It’s possible that Mayfield looks just as good in December of 2026 as he did in December of 2024.

If not, the Bucs are not going to get anywhere near the postseason.

And the future will suddenly look a lot different in Tampa Bay.

____


©2026 Tampa Bay Times. Visit tampabay.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus