Dieter Kurtenbach: Stop blaming the pass rush -- the 49ers' secondary is the defense's real issue
Published in Football
The San Francisco 49ers have a championship-caliber offense, a physical defensive front and a defensive secondary that’s currently doing its best impression of a screen door on a submarine.
In Sunday’s wild 46-40 win over the Dallas Cowboys, Brock Purdy and Christian McCaffrey spent three hours bailing out a secondary that’s officially hit rock bottom.
You can’t win a Super Bowl when your cornerbacks and safeties treat opposing wide receivers like they’re carrying the plague.
Right now, San Francisco’s pass defense isn’t just a weakness. It’s an active liability that threatens to torpedo a Super Bowl bid.
The numbers from Arlington are ugly enough to make defensive coordinator Raheem Morris reach for the Pepto-Bismol. Dak Prescott completed 30 of 51 passes for 343 yards and five touchdowns, turning George Pickens into prime Jerry Rice with 11 catches for 145 yards and three scores.
And it wasn’t just Pickens. CeeDee Lamb and Ryan Flournoy also waltzed into the end zone, while Prescott posted a 103.6 passer rating despite facing 14 pressures on 54 dropbacks in a game where the Cowboys spent most of the second half chasing the game in hurry-up offense against four-man rushes.
This isn’t a pass-rush problem, no matter how loudly the box-score watchers scream about sacks. Nick Bosa, DeForest Buckner and Mykel Williams are generating push, and the run defense held Dallas to four yards per carry Sunday. The D-line isn’t great, but it’s good enough.
But none of what happens up front matters when the back end collapses in two seconds flat. You can’t expect a defensive line to rack up sacks when opposing quarterbacks have wide-open primary reads before they even hit the top of their drop.
Prescott didn’t even bother looking toward Renardo Green for most of the afternoon, and it wasn’t out of respect. Why bother testing a healthy corner when Deommodore Lenoir is visibly hobbled by a foot injury and playing like he’s running in wet cement? Just throw it his way, which meant throwing it to Pickens.
Lenoir was so compromised against Pickens that Morris had no business leaving him out there on an island. And yet, what was the alternative? Then Green exited with a back injury, leaving the 49ers to trot out rookie cornerback Ephesians Prysock, who currently wears a giant neon target on his helmet every time he steps onto the turf. And that’s to say nothing of slotback Upton Stout, who is being attacked relentlessly in the pass game as well.
Meanwhile, the safety rotation has become a weekly game of Russian roulette with three loaded chambers. Whether it’s Ji’Ayir Brown, Malik Mustapha, or Marques Sigle, nobody is communicating, nobody is taking proper angles, and nobody is making plays on the ball. How can Morris pick his top two when not a single one has stepped forward to claim the gig?
This isn’t a one-week fluke, either; it’s part of a larger trend. When the Raiders are forcing communication issues and picking up big plays, you know you have a problem. It was there for everyone who cared to look just a bit past the obvious to see last week. The game before that, at Atlanta, wasn’t much better. This has been an issue that has been apparent since the second half of the Monday night game against Washington.
And yet, this week, general manager John Lynch sat on his hands at the trade deadline, electing not to add a single viable cornerback or safety despite glaring red flags. With backup slot Nate Hobbs still injured and no reinforcements walking through the door at cornerback or safety, the 49ers are stuck with the deck they dealt themselves.
Sure enough, Prescott made this secondary easy work Sunday on an average time to throw of 2.8 seconds.
That’s hardly “all day to throw.”
Purdy can’t post a 154.5 passer rating every Sunday. McCaffrey can’t pile up 223 total yards and three touchdowns every time the secondary forgets how to cover a post route.
Eventually, the 49ers are going to face a team that can actually slow down their offense — starting with a brutal matchup against Brian Flores and the Minnesota Vikings next Sunday night. Then comes the Seahawks.
And while the Niners’ defense won’t face a top-tier test for a minute, Patrick Mahomes and the Kansas City Chiefs are waiting on Dec. 27.
That game is a litmus test of how well Morris has stabilized the ship. Because the issue for the 49ers won’t truly be in the regular season. No, it will be in the playoffs, when teams like the Packers, Bears, and Lions — all of which can put up 500 yards on a bad pass defense like the Niners have been the last few weeks — loom.
And that’s a one-and-done situation.
If Morris doesn’t pick two safeties — any two will do — and re-construct a secondary that once had serious promise but has completely lost its way, Purdy’s MVP-caliber magic is going to run out before it’s really needed.
Because right now, Kyle Shanahan’s offense is playing with zero margin for error, forced to score 40 just to survive 60 minutes. That’s a fun way to go 8-1 in November, and a guaranteed way to go home early in January.
____
©2026 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit at mercurynews.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments