Dave Hyde: Who wouldn't want Aaron Rodgers for four elite years?

Dave Hyde, South Florida Sun-Sentinel on

Published in Football

That chipping noise across the NFL is star quarterbacks tearing down the wall of feudal power. Aaron Rodgers demands out of Green Bay.

Russell Wilson says he’s not happy in Seattle. Chip.

Deshaun Watson tells Houston he’s played his last down there (before falling into a quagmire of legal problems from sexual assault allegations). Chip.

This has NBA-style ramifications for the NFL as each of these franchise quarterbacks moves onto the open market. Why throw a dart at the board hoping on a young quarterback? Why not making your team instantly relevant since The Untouchables are now The Unhappiest?

Tom Brady showed the way for quarterbacks. Add this to the legacy of his mantel of the greatest player of all time. He didn’t just set up his exit from New England. His absence showed them for what they were — an average team without him — while turning perennial loser Tampa Bay into a winner.

Unhappy quarterbacks aren’t unusual. Terry Bradshaw criticized Rodgers for being so “sensitive” in Green Bay. But Bradshaw didn’t return to Pittsburgh until three decades after his retirement because he was so put off by how Pittsburgh treated him.


Dan Marino, tired of four straight non-playoff seasons and perhaps coach Don Shula’s ways, brokered the idea of a mutually beneficial trade from the Dolphins after the 1989 season. In a world without Twitter, it still caused a seismic outcry. “How dare he,” was the common theme. Players were treated as feudal property at the time.

“With him or with anyone else, if a trade would help the club, I would give it serious consideration,’' Shula said then. “But I’d never trade him and hurt the team.”

Marino’s request went nowhere. It turned out fine for him from the view of decades later. He’s now a quiet adviser inside his one and only team. But would he have won a ring if traded to a veteran Philadelphia team as rumored? Would that itch have been scratched?

The looming question as first posed by Brady is if quarterbacks should have a voice inside the team’s decisions. Answer: It depends on the quarterback. Dolphins GM Chris Grier nearly chuckled at a question about whether Tua Tagovaila stating the offense needed speed played into the team’s decision to get faster at receiver this offseason. Tua played one marginal year. There’s no weight to his voice just yet.


swipe to next page
©2021 South Florida Sun-Sentinel. Visit Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.