Review: Mahershala Ali makes this 'Detective' worthwhile

Robert Lloyd, Los Angeles Times on

Published in Entertainment News

When the first season of HBO's "True Detective" arrived in 2014, it was as praised and argued over as any series in television's increasingly self-conscious New Golden/Platinum Age. Starring Matthew McConaughey and Woody Harrelson as an odder-than-usual odd couple of Louisiana policemen chasing an old case into the present, it was brilliant and maddening and new in ways that seem much less new now. In the years since, we have become accustomed to slow-building television, anthologies and the notion that an entire series might be written or directed by a single person -- crime novelist Nic Pizzolatto and "Beasts of No Nation" director Cary Joji Fukunaga, respectively, in this case.

A second season the following year, written almost wholly by Pizzolatto with a rotating crew of directors, was set in a fictional Southern California town and starred Colin Farrell, Rachel McAdams and Taylor Kitsch as law enforcement officers from different departments brought together on an increasingly convoluted case involving Vince Vaughn as a crook in big trouble. It was less well-received critically -- though not the bloodbath you may remember -- but was not without its points of interest as it moved its sometimes tiring way to an ending partly cribbed from "Casablanca."

Once again, the series, which returns Sunday, is mainly Pizzolatto's work, with "Deadwood" creator David Milch co-writing one episode and Graham Gordy, another. (There will be several directors, including Pizzolatto himself.)

Wayne Hays (Mahershala Ali, the series' first black lead) and Roland West (Stephen Dorff) are the partnered cops here, Arkansas state police detectives. Both are Vietnam vets. Roland is more relaxed, though not exactly well-adjusted. Wayne, who developed preternatural tracking skills through his wartime specialty -- "long range reconnaissance" ("Drop him in the jungle alone he comes out two or three weeks later with scalps") -- has a stricter code. He stops Roland from shooting a fox; he doesn't want to go to a whorehouse ("guess I'm a romantic"). But bucking a tradition in crime fiction, they are generally in sync.

Like the first season, the story runs in multiple timelines. In 1980, the two are investigating the disappearance of a young brother and sister in a northwest Arkansas small town. In 1990, the case has been reopened, and they become partners again, just as Wayne's wife, Amelia (Carmen Ejogo), is about to publish a book -- eventually considered "a classic of literary non-fiction" -- on the case. (In a nice touch, Roland wears the same Western jacket in 1990 as in 1980.) In 2015, Wayne is being interviewed for a documentary on the subject, both prompting him to relive the case and challenging his ability to do it. Afflicted with an unnamed dementia, he is losing great tracts of his past, even as it seems to invade his waking present.

In either conscious callbacks to the first season or just ruts in which the writer is stuck, there are strange folk-art objects as clues, a corpse in an attitude of prayer, a hint of powerful people doing something in secret. There was a missing child in Season 1 as well. As before, the series looks good, with place and atmosphere well evoked (if somewhat less exquisitely than by original director of photography Adam Arkapaw).

Sponsored Video Stories from LifeZette

It moves slowly. (There is not much action, as we usually understand it, in the five of eight episodes available for review.)

It remains a talky show, if a less self-consciously eloquent one; Wayne is a man of few words and Roland only a few more. Once again, it's well-cast and played -- Dorff, currently appearing in Fox's "Star" and mostly relegated to thrillers and horror films this century, may get a McConaughey moment out of this. Scoot McNairy and Mamie Gummer, as the parents of the missing children; Michael Greyeyes as a local scavenger of trash; and Jon Tenney, as a lawyer on different sides of the case in 1980 and 1990 are some of the vivid characters who fill out the narrative. But it's mostly Wayne's story and Ali's show -- he is already having his moment, with big awards for "Green Book" this year and "Moonlight" two years ago.

That Wayne and Amelia are among the few people of color seen here can seem odd -- we are in the South, after all -- but it's consistent with the demographics of northwestern Arkansas. Race is occasionally a point, if not exactly an issue in the five episodes I was able to watch. ("How is it here?" 1980 Wayne asks Amelia, a black woman teaching white kids. "It's fine. It's good really, for what it is. I hear something now and then. They're all poor around here; that's the main thing.")

The woman interviewing Wayne for the documentary in 2015 asks if he ever felt that his superiors discounted his leads, "because I'm interested in the intersectionality of marginalized groups within authoritarian and systemic racist structures." Wayne says no, but in an earlier timeline, he makes it clear to Roland, "I know where I am in a way you will never understand."


swipe to next page


blog comments powered by Disqus

--Ads from Google--

Social Connections


The Barn Rudy Park Gary Varvel Working it Out Wee Pals Hi and Lois