Conservative group sues to overturn Amendment 87, Colorado's voter-approved income tax overhaul
Published in News & Features
DENVER — A conservative advocacy group that led a failed bid to defeat Colorado’s graduated income tax proposal at the ballot box earlier this month is pursuing legal action in an attempt to overturn it.
Advance Colorado filed a lawsuit Thursday in Denver District Court on behalf of two Republican state legislators, Sens. Barb Kirkmeyer of Brighton and Byron Pelton of Sterling. The suit alleges that Amendment 87 violated the Colorado Constitution by bundling issues that should have been broken into separate ballot measures.
The core of their argument centers around the ballot measure’s change to the Taxpayer’s Bill of Rights, or TABOR, a 1992 voter-approved amendment to the state constitution.
Amendment 87, which passed with 51.7% of the vote, abolishes a provision in TABOR that requires all taxable income to be taxed at one rate, currently 4.4%. The measure also adds, in state statute, a progressive rate that ratchets up the percentage paid in taxes by higher earners and businesses, with income over $500,000 taxed at higher rates than the current tax. But it cuts taxes for the vast majority of Coloradans.
The new income tax structure is projected to generate around $2 billion in additional state revenue in its first year, money that lawmakers will be directed to spend on healthcare, childcare and education.
Advance Colorado’s lawsuit claims that changing both the constitution and state statute under one measure violated TABOR, which it says requires tax increases to be presented to voters as a standalone ballot issue.
“It’s clear that Amendment 87 should have been filed as two measures, not a single one,” Kirkmeyer, who ran unsuccessfully for governor in the Republican primary, said in a statement Thursday. “The constitution wasn’t followed, and voters will pay the price if this measure isn’t overturned.”
Conservatives previously challenged the ballot measure’s two-track approach to changing state tax law by saying it violated Colorado’s single subject rule. That rule requires all proposed constitutional amendments or statutory changes to be limited to a single issue.
Conservative groups appealed the state Title Board’s decision approving the ballot language, which did not find a violation of the single subject rule. In April, the Colorado Supreme Court reaffirmed the Title Board’s decision. In late October, the state Supreme Court rejected another lawsuit seeking to disqualify Amendment 87 from the ballot based on how petitions were gathered.
The new lawsuit filed Thursday also claims that information on Amendment 87 included in the state-approved Blue Book, a nonpartisan voter guide, contained “objectively false information” about the measure’s fiscal impact to taxpayers.
As one example, the lawsuit says the Blue Book falsely claimed that taxpayers making between $500,000 and $1 million would see an average $284 tax cut because of what it says was a “methodological error.” The lawsuit says taxpayers who fall within that income spectrum will actually see a $2,651 tax increase on average.
Advance’s president, Michael Fields, was a driving force behind the opposition to Amendment 87. Voters not only narrowly passed the graduated income tax measure, but nearly 53% rejected a competing proposal from Advance, Proposition 136, that would have prevented the state’s income tax rate from rising higher than 4.4%.
Advance said on Thursday that it’s pursuing several potential ballot measures for the 2027 election that are aimed at reversing 87’s tax impacts.
“When people see the economic destruction that Amendment 87 will cause, they will want immediate reform,” Fields said in a statement.
________
©2026 MediaNews Group, Inc. Visit at denverpost.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments