Current News

/

ArcaMax

Lawyers for indicted Va. lawmaker Louise Lucas ask judge to sanction US attorney general, FBI director for statements at news conference

Peter Dujardin and Nori Leybengrub, Daily Press on

Published in News & Features

Attorneys for state Sen. Louise Lucas are asking a federal judge to sanction top U.S. Justice Department officials over comments they made about a pending marijuana conspiracy case against her the day she was charged.

The motion, filed Sunday, asks U.S. District Judge Jamar K. Walker to sanction U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche and FBI Director Kash Patel over comments about Lucas at an Oct. 22 news conference.

Blanche and Patel flew to Hampton Roads that morning to announce the 45-page indictment. They spoke at the U.S. Attorney’s Office in downtown Norfolk.

Earlier that day, Lucas — the powerful chair of the Senate Finance and Appropriations Committee — was charged with orchestrating a racketeering conspiracy to illegally sell marijuana.

She was also accused of attempting to manipulate the state’s fledgling marijuana licensure process so her family could benefit. Lucas’ two daughters, grandson and three others also were charged.

Lucas’ lawyers wrote in a Nov. 15 motion, the “two most senior law enforcement officials in the country,” and the top federal prosecutor in the Eastern District of Virginia “declared Senator Lucas guilty” when they spoke as the news conference.

Lucas’ lawyers argued that the officials’ “extra-judicial” comments went beyond the indictment, branding the senator as guilty in the public eye.

The news conference, social media posts and subsequent nationwide news coverage, Lucas’ lawyers argued, violate the federal court’s rules governing criminal prosecutions and threaten to taint Lucas’ jury pool and her right to a fair and impartial trial.

Posts on the Department of Justice’s account on the social media site X — linked to a live-stream of the news conference — have nearly 200,000 views, Lucas’ lawyers wrote in their motion for sanctions.

Patel “made the most flagrant statements” of the three who spoke, Lucas’ lawyers contend.

The FBI director told a room packed with reporters that “as alleged by the attorney general,” Lucas and her family “accumulated nearly $5 million in ill-gotten gains through her criminal enterprise” over the past five years.

“During her time as Virginia State Senator, instead of enforcing the law, she was actually breaking the law, as alleged in the indictment, and then using her position of power and public trust to deflect and defend against her own criminal enterprise,” Patel said. “Truly the epitome of hypocrisy for a public official.”

The motion contends that Patel’s statements are not “recitations of charges,” but take “the central contested facts” in the case as “established truths.”

“Strikingly, the statement that Senator Lucas accumulated nearly $5 million in ill-gotten gains is not even a fact alleged in the Indictment,” the motion says. The intent of Patel’s statement, Lucas’ lawyers maintain, “was to inflate the seriousness” of the allegations.

In the days after the appearance, The Virginian-Pilot and Daily Press asked the U.S. Attorney’s Office and FBI where Patel obtained his information about “nearly $5 million in ill-gotten gains.”

The U.S. Attorney’s Office referred the newspapers’ inquiries to the FBI. The FBI referred them back to the prosecutor’s office.

“Because this case is now in the adjudication phase, we are unable to provide additional information beyond what has already been publicly released,” a spokeswoman for FBI Norfolk, Cassandra Temple, wrote Oct. 27.

Though Patel isn’t a lawyer, the motion contends he was still covered by a local court rule barring attorneys and law enforcement from making prejudicial out-of-court statements about cases with which they are associated.

The motion notes that as the FBI director’s direct supervisor, Blanche “held the authority to prevent or curtail” Patel’s statements. Blanche heard Patel’s statements “as they were made, had every opportunity to interject or disavow them, and he did neither.

“His failure to do so, at an event he controlled, is itself sanctionable,” the motion asserts.

Blanche is accused of making concerning statements of his own.

For example, he said the charges against Lucas “reflect the alleged behavior of a public servant who put her own financial interests before the people she was elected to serve” — a line that later received over 50,000 views on X.

“The Department of Justice intends to prove that Sen. Lucas violated the trust of the people of Portsmouth and Chesapeake, Virginia, and of her state Senate colleagues,” Blanche added.

The U.S. Attorney’s Office’s release about Lucas’ arrest included standard language saying that a defendant is innocent until proven guilty and indictments are mere allegations. But no one said anything along those lines at the news conference, the motion contends.

 

Under Local Criminal Rule 57.1 in the Eastern District of Virginia, after criminal charges are filed, attorneys or law enforcement officers associated with the prosecution or defense are barred from making public statements voicing an opinion on the case’s merits or evidence, or “any opinion about an accused person’s guilt or innocence.”

Prosecutors especially are held to a high standard when it comes to making comments about ongoing cases, because they represent the authority of the government.

“An official’s standing as a senior prosecutor is not a defense” to violating the rule, the motion from Lucas’ lawyers say. “In fact it is an aggravating factor,” given that statements from a ranking official at a national news conference are likely to be widely disseminated.

Apart from Patel and Blanche, the motion also contends that First Assistant U.S. Attorney Theophani Stamos, the acting head of the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Eastern District of Virginia, also made improper statements Oct. 22.

At the news conference, Stamos said the charges against Lucas “are not limited to public corruption, but also involve public safety.”

“We see time and again the dangers of the presence and use of firearms in conjunction with drug trafficking,” she said.

The comment, the motion contends, “holds Sen. Lucas out as a present danger to the community before any evidence has been tested at trial.”

Ryan Eichelberger, Lucas’ grandson and the manager of her Portsmouth CBD store, is the only defendant in the indictment charged with possessing a firearm while maintaining a drug-involved premises.

The motion notes the indictment does not allege firearms were ever fired, “or used in a manner inconsistent with what they were — lawfully owned and possessed by security guards at a store that does retail cash transactions.”

Lucas’ attorneys wrote in their motion that it is “highly unusual” for the country’s top law enforcement official and the FBI director to attend and address the public announcing the indictment of a sitting politician.

For example, the motion says the 2023 indictment of U.S. Rep. George Santos on various fraud charges was not announced by the U.S. Attorney General or FBI director at a national news conference. Neither were the indictments of U.S. Reps. William Jefferson, Duncan Hunter and Robert Menendez for public corruption charges.

Lucas’ lawyers ask Walker to find that Blanche, Patel and Stamos violated the local court rule through their public statements and enter an order “prohibiting further extrajudicial statements” about the case’s merits.

The attorneys also ask that Walker take steps to protect Lucas’ right to a fair trial, such as by expanding the juror pool. And they asked that the alleged violations be referred to a disciplinary proceeding.

Moreover, the motion requests that Walker order the Justice Department to remove the October news conference, and statements made about it, from its website and social media accounts, while preserving copies of the public comments to be used as evidence in future litigation.

The attorneys also requested the DOJ disclose how many views the news conference, its webpage and any related social media posts, received.

Lucas’ lawyers wrote that they reserve the right to request additional remedies in the future — “up to and including dismissal of the indictment or a significant delay of the trial to dissipate the taint of the unfair media publicity.”

At Monday’s arraignment hearing for Lucas and two other defendants, Walker gave prosecutors until Dec. 7 to respond to the motion, with a follow-up reply from Lucas’ attorneys due by Dec. 14.

A spokesperson for the U.S. Attorney’s Office in Alexandria declined to comment on the motion for sanctions. “We respectfully refer to court documents,” he said.

A Justice Department spokesperson in Washington referred a reporter to the 45-page indictment.

“The Department remains confident in its case and will not comment further on pending litigation,” she wrote in an email.

Jeffrey Robinson, an attorney for Lucas with the Washington firm of Lewis Baach Kaufmann Middlemiss, declined to comment on the motion, saying “the filings speak for themselves.”

_____


©2026 Daily Press. Visit at dailypress.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus