Current News

/

ArcaMax

NYC public school enrollment suffers largest drop since COVID, raising specter of cuts, closures

Cayla Bamberger, New York Daily News on

Published in News & Features

NEW YORK — New York City public school enrollment fell by 2.6% this fall, setting a new record for the largest post-pandemic drop in a single year, according to new data released Monday.

The number of students in the city’s schools decreased by 22,760 since last year to 863,100 schoolchildren — a decline that came even as the Mamdani administration opened new childcare programs that added to the total enrollment. This year’s decline continued an over a decade-long trend of shrinking enrollment in the city’s public schools, sparking debates over budget cuts and school closures.

The K-12 schools lost 23,018 students, the data showed, compounding ongoing financial challenges created by the drop. A recent report by City Comptroller Mark Levine found the enrollment decline reflected a general decrease in the number of school-aged children living in New York, suggesting record-low birth rates and an affordability crisis forcing young families to leave the city were driving the shift.

The plummeting accelerated during COVID-19 as some families left the five boroughs, while others remained in the city but chose other schools or homeschooling when the district public schools were closed.

The downturn finally started to stabilize with the arrival of school-aged migrant children, but began decreasing again last school year amid President Trump’s federal immigration crackdown. Enrollment fell last year by 2.4%, which had been the biggest post-pandemic drop until this year broke the record.

The consequences have been dubbed a “small school crisis,” where principals of declining student bodies have struggled to offer a full range of academic classes, clubs and sports teams — all while costs continued to rise. Chancellor Kamar Samuels recently launched the process to close a handful of tiny schools and merge others, but not to the extent necessary to fix the problem.

“A school that is robustly enrolled … has the capacity to offer advanced coursework, extracurricular activities (and) rigor,” Samuels said at a Queens town hall last month. “This is what we are really thinking about.”

“Arts programs, STEM programs. When our schools can offer these things, they are really enriching places.”

In a news release, the Department of Education pointed to investments in childcare programs and preschool special education as some of the steps the city is taking in response to affordability challenges and changing demographics. In a break from tradition, neither the mayor nor the chancellor commented on the data in the release.

The data is preliminary and subject to change if more students enroll before the end of the school year, or education officials revise the data during the auditing process.

 

The decline comes as more local officials and budget watchdogs have raised concerns about the long-term sustainability of a policy known as “hold harmless,” in which schools that have lost or are projected to lose enrollment are spared budget cuts.

The cost of hold harmless, which started as an emergency measure during the pandemic, reached nearly $290 million this year, roughly doubling the funding required to maintain the policy, according to an analysis by Chalkbeat New York, the nonprofit education news source.

At issue is that schools are largely funded on a per-student basis. When a school loses enrollment, then, it also loses the funding that follows that student based on a weighted formula, which rises or falls based on a child’s educational needs.

But the per-pupil formula is not a perfect system. At all but the city’s most rapidly shrinking schools, even classrooms with fewer students require the same number of teachers and administrators, and therefore the same budget levels for staff payroll. More than a half-decade since the start of hold harmless, an immediate elimination of the policy would likely mean principals must let go of teachers or cut programming.

A public schools spokeswoman did not immediately comment on the question of whether the Department of Education plans to ask principals to adjust their budgets in the middle of the school year based on the new enrollment data, as was standard practice before COVID-19.

The School Construction Authority has projected the public schools could lose another 128,000 students by the 2034-35 school year.

“More to come,” Samuels told reporters on Friday when asked about the future of the hold harmless. “We’re having conversations. More to come, especially with our City Hall partners.”

_____


©2026 New York Daily News. Visit nydailynews.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus