Current News



Supreme Court leans in favor of Purdue Pharma deal with $6 billion from Sacklers

David G. Savage, Los Angeles Times on

Published in News & Features

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court justices sounded Monday as if they will uphold a huge bankruptcy deal that includes $6 billion from the Sackler family to help the nation and tens of thousands of victims recover from the opioid crisis.

Most of the justices said the deal looked to be the best possible outcome, even though it gave the Sacklers a shield from future lawsuits.

Most of their questions were critical of the Biden administration's claim that the deal should not go forward because the Sacklers are not bankrupt.

Justice Brett M. Kavanaugh said tens of thousands of families directly affected by OxyContin "overwhelmingly approve of this settlement," he told a Justice Department lawyer. "The federal government, with no stake in this at all, is telling the families we will not give you a prompt payment and to allow this money to go to the states for prevent programs to prevent future overdoses and future victims. And all in exchange for this somewhat theoretical idea that they'll be able to recover money down the road from the Sacklers themselves."

Justice Elena Kagan agreed.

"It's overwhelming, the support for this deal, and among people who have no love for the Sacklers. Your position rests on a lot of highfalutin principles of bankruptcy law ... that you can come in here and blow up the deal," she told Deputy Solicitor General Curtis Gannon. "The federal government is standing in the way against a huge, huge majority of claimants who have decided that if this provision goes under, they're going to end up with nothing."


State attorneys from all 50 states agreed to the deal on the grounds it would provide money for addiction treatment programs. If finally approved, the deal includes smaller payments for the tens of thousands of victims of the opioid crisis. About 97% of the individuals claimants who cast votes said they approved the deal.

But the Justice Department raised a last-minute objection and argued that wealthy people like the Sacklers should not be allowed to use the bankruptcy system to shield themselves from future lawsuits. While their company Purdue Pharma has filed for bankruptcy, the same is not true for the members of the Sackler family.

They originally offered about $4 billion to settle all the claims and later raised the total to $6 billion.

Justice Samuel A. Alito Jr. said it may not be realistic to obtain more. Their assets may not be "reachable," he said, because they are held outside the United States.


swipe to next page

©2023 Los Angeles Times. Visit Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.


blog comments powered by Disqus