Analysis: Should Orioles trade for Ketel Marte? The case for and against.
Published in Baseball
BALTIMORE — The Orioles know how to make a splash.
Whether it’s trading Adley Rutschman at the deadline, signing Pete Alonso away from New York or swinging a deal for Corbin Burnes just before spring training, president of baseball operations Mike Elias hasn’t been afraid to make waves across the industry.
He’s in a position to do so again this offseason. The Orioles are exploring myriad options to get the organization back to the playoffs in 2027 after falling short of that goal each of the past two years. One avenue they’ve considered is trading for Arizona Diamondbacks second baseman Ketel Marte, according to multiple reports including MLB.com.
Marte, 33, has been one of the best players at his position for much of the past decade. The three-time All-Star, two-time Silver Slugger Award winner and 2023 National League Championship Series MVP is the runner-up to Jose Altuve in nearly every major offensive statistic among qualified second basemen since making his MLB debut in 2015.
A switch-hitter with platoon splits that favor his results against left-handers, Marte would be an immediate upgrade over Jackson Holliday, who could slot in anywhere at the top of the Orioles’ lineup. He makes consistent contact, draws walks, hits for home run power and plays above-average defense. Marte is a bona fide star and impact player.
He’s also signed long term. The Diamondbacks inked Marte to a new extension in 2025, and he’s owed $76 million over the next four seasons with performance bonuses and a $11.5 million player option for 2031. His $16.64 million average annual value (AAV) would be the Orioles’ second-highest luxury tax figure behind only Alonso’s $31 million.
But while Marte’s track record on the field paints a picture of a player worth that kind of investment, dealing for him would also come with considerable risk.
Marte’s relationship with the Diamondbacks became strained this summer when he failed to show up for a game in Boston, leaving the team scrambling. After being placed on the restricted list and later the injured list, he created further distraction when he was spotted at a casino during a game. Marte later issued apologies to his coaches and teammates.
It’s an apparent reason why the Diamondbacks appear to be listening to offers for Marte this offseason after trade rumors rang hollow a year ago. Another is perhaps because Marte took a step back in 2026 with a .748 OPS that was well below the .887 mark he posted over the previous three seasons.
Marte started swinging at a lot more pitches outside the strike zone, and he didn’t make as much hard contact, though his swing speed and strikeout rate remained steady. He still cleared the 20-homer threshold for the fourth-straight year, but his on-base percentage dropped 60 points to .316 for his lowest figure since his sophomore season in 2016.
At 33 years old, Marte is already past the conventional prime years for a position player, and his contract has escalating salaries that would tie him to the team through his age-37 seasons. Then there’s the cost it would take to complete the trade. While the Orioles have a restocked farm system and a logjam on the infield that needs clearing, the Diamondbacks would require a hefty price to move one of their franchise cornerstones.
It would be a drastic measure, not that the Orioles’ infield has been productive enough to fend off the notion that a shake-up is required. Holliday, their No. 1 overall pick in 2022, has a .654 OPS through three seasons at the MLB level, and his defense at second base is just as much a work in progress. Though he’s still only 22 years old, the Orioles’ urgency to return to the postseason might not afford them the patience to wait for him to develop.
However, the Diamondbacks might prefer plucking from the Orioles’ stockpile of young pitching rather than a deal built around Holliday. The Arizona Republic reported at the general manager meetings last week that GM Mike Hazen spoke of his regret for prioritizing MLB-ready players over higher-upside prospects in past trades of franchise stars.
Complicating matters further is that Marte has a full no-trade clause as a player with 10-and-5 rights (10 years of MLB service time, including five with his current team). He would need to approve any trade and has not made any public request for a change of scenery.
If the Orioles pulled it off, the addition of Marte would be one of the splashiest moves of the offseason. There’s plenty of upside that comes with acquiring a player of his caliber, but a lot would have to break right for him to be anchoring the Orioles’ lineup in the middle of a pennant race next fall — or any other fall after that.
____
©2026 Baltimore Sun. Visit baltimoresun.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.







Comments