The Lightning missed their first chance to secure a spot in the Stanley Cup final.
Game 5 had been lucky for Tampa Bay and Tuesday's lined up to repeat the previous two series that went into overtime. The Islanders had the touch this time, however, pulling out a double-overtime 2-1 win over the Lightning at Edmonton's Rogers Place.
Tampa Bay still leads the series 3-2 and will get another opportunity to advance at 8 p.m. Thursday.
Center Anthony Cirelli's shot sailed wide and then moments later, defenseman Kevin Shattenkirk whiffed, creating a turnover. Winger Jordan Eberle picked up the puck, raced down the ice and beat Vasilevskiy to keep the Islanders' season alive.
This low-scoring, low-shot game fits the Islanders' style more directly than the Lightning's. But even while being limited to about two-thirds of their regular-season average, Tampa Bay managed to substantially outshoot the Islanders.
The Tampa Bay Lightning go down 2-1 in double overtime against the New York Islanders as Islanders' Jordan Eberle scores the game winning goal forcing a game 6 in the NHL Conference Finals.
Goalie Andrei Vasilevskiy went 12 minutes without seeing a shot at one point across the second and third periods.
Until overtime, the goals scored came from defensemen. Ryan Pulock put the Islanders on the board with a rocket from the left point with 4:19 left in the first period.
Victor Hedman, who is scoring at a career-high rate, matched him in the second period. He sank to about the top of the left circle to pounce on a rebound and place it top shelf.
Those stood as the only goals for more than 50 minutes into the second overtime.
Visit the Tampa Bay Times (St. Petersburg, Fla.) at www.tampabay.com(c)2020 Tampa Bay Times (St. Petersburg, Fla.), Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.