From the Left



'Dreamers' need to get out of their own way

Dana Milbank on

I'm sympathetic to the dreamers' demand for immediate action. Greisa Martinez Rosas, director of advocacy for United We Dream, tells me that her group has "called out Trump as a white nationalist" and has identified the many Republicans who oppose DACA as "dream killers." The group's recent attacks on Democrats reflect desperation as time runs out for DACA.

The problem for Democrats is that the party is a collection of one-issue entities, which too often use internecine disputes for fundraising and, collectively, thwart any attempt at a cohesive progressive strategy.

The dreamers' attacks on Democrats are particularly counterproductive because there is no ideological disagreement. Senate Minority Leader Charles E. Schumer and other Democrats are playing a chess game: They know Republicans want an increase in defense spending, and they're seeking to use that as leverage to gain domestic spending increases, renewal of the Children's Health Insurance Program, disaster relief and DACA legislation.

United We Dream, by contrast, understandably wants the DACA legislation above all. It is demanding that Democrats instigate a government shutdown on Jan. 19 by refusing to support a short-term spending bill that doesn't legalize the dreamers. Those who favor this approach argue that Trump and Republicans would be blamed for the pain of a shutdown, and Republicans would then legalize the dreamers.

Maybe -- or maybe the Democrats would be blamed, and their political and legislative hopes (and those of the dreamers) dashed for years.

Instead of training their fire on those who support them, dreamers and their supporters could use their prodigious energy on the 34 House Republicans who said they support legalization. These Republicans could force House Speaker Paul D. Ryan to include DACA in the spending bill. Also on Tuesday, a federal judge ordered that the DACA protections remain in place while a court case proceeds. And Ryan softened his earlier insistence that DACA not be considered as part of a spending bill.

Meanwhile, dreamers and the Democrats will likely gain more leverage against Trump and the Republicans with the approach of March 5, the day the DACA program, per Trump's order, is set to expire. Trump, who had made clear he has no appetite for deporting the dreamers, would then have to capitulate -- and Democrats could get a better deal for the dreamers.


Patience has been paying off for the Democrats. In his marathon televised session with lawmakers at the White House on Tuesday, Trump softened his position on the border wall and suggested a DACA deal could be had while postponing thornier issues such as chain migration.

Dreamers will win this fight -- if they don't mow down their friends first.


Follow Dana Milbank on Twitter, @Milbank.

(c) 2018, Washington Post Writers Group



blog comments powered by Disqus

Social Connections


Ken Catalino Chip Bok Mike Luckovich Gary Varvel Nick Anderson Mike Lester