Politics

/

ArcaMax

The Philly DA's suit against Musk's $1 million giveaway lacked proof and made 'unpersuasive' arguments, judge says

Chris Palmer, The Philadelphia Inquirer on

Published in Political News

PHILADELPHIA — District Attorney Larry Krasner’s election-related lawsuit against Elon Musk — in which Philadelphia’s top prosecutor accused the tech billionaire of running an illegal lottery by giving money to Pennsylvania voters — failed to establish proof that the contest met even the most basic definition of a lottery, the judge overseeing the case said.

Common Pleas Court Judge Angelo Foglietta, who last week rejected Krasner’s request for an injunction against Musk and his America PAC, wrote in an opinion filed late Tuesday that Krasner and his attorneys offered little evidence and made “unpersuasive” arguments in their attempt to have Musk’s daily $1 million giveaway barred from operating in the state.

Although Krasner accused Musk of misleading contest entrants by suggesting that anyone had a chance to win, Foglietta said, PAC officials provided documents and “credible testimony” to show that winners were actually chosen through a multistep vetting process — and then expected to serve as spokespersons for the PAC, making them de facto employees.

Moreover, the DA presented no witnesses to support the notion that entrants felt duped, Foglietta said, and he ignored or downplayed portions of Musk’s comments explaining that winners would need to speak on behalf of the PAC, which was established to promote the candidacy of Republican nominee Donald Trump, now the president-elect.

In addition, the judge said, contest entrants did not pay to enter the sweepstakes, as is the case in a typical lottery. And although Krasner asserted that the contest was a scam similar to those in other fraud probes his office had conducted, Foglietta said, the DA made that statement “without detailing the facts of those other investigations or how they were similar to the facts of this case.”

“Although (Krasner) alleges that America PAC and Elon Musk ‘scammed’ people,” Foglietta wrote, “… DA Krasner failed to provide any evidence of misuse beyond mere speculation.”

Krasner, in a statement Wednesday, said: “We respectfully disagree with the Judge’s opinion in this matter.”

Then, in an apparent reference to proposed class-action suits filed against Musk and his PAC in other states, he added: “We note that there is litigation on this issue in other jurisdictions. Stay tuned.” He did not comment further.

Foglietta’s reasoning appears to end, at least for now, the legal proceedings between Krasner and Musk, whose wealth and proximity to power have only grown since Trump won the election last week. Trump said Tuesday night that once he is sworn into office, Musk would cochair a new committee to reduce government spending.

Krasner, a Democrat, sued Musk and his PAC last month, saying they were violating state lottery and consumer protection laws by distributing cash to registered voters in Pennsylvania and other battleground states ahead of the presidential election.

To enter the $1 million daily sweepstakes, residents — who were required to be registered voters — had to sign a petition organized by the PAC affirming their support for free speech and the right to bear arms.

 

Musk said he hoped the giveaways would drive up Republican voter registration numbers. But several election-law experts — and the Justice Department — warned that the contest appeared to violate federal laws banning giving money or other things of value in exchange for votes or registering to vote.

Still, Krasner’s lawsuit was the first legal action taken against the sweepstakes. And it took a different approach, targeting Musk under state laws that prohibit anyone but the state from running a lottery in Pennsylvania. He also accused the PAC of failing to provide information on how it was protecting the personal information of entrants.

But on Nov. 4, after a daylong hearing in City Hall, Foglietta rejected Krasner’s bid for an injunction to stop the contest from operating in Pennsylvania before the election.

And in his opinion Tuesday, the judge said the timing of Krasner’s request represented another fatal flaw.

By the time the case was heard in court, Foglietta said, the PAC’s sweepstakes had only one day to go before it would shut down — and the only remaining winner at the time was a registered voter in Michigan.

An injunction, therefore, would not have prevented any future payouts in Pennsylvania, the judge said.

Krasner’s attorneys said that did not preclude the need for a legal ruling against the contest.

Foglietta disagreed.

“This Court is not here to enter superfluous orders,” he wrote.

_____


©2024 The Philadelphia Inquirer. Visit inquirer.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

 

Related Channels

ACLU

ACLU

By The ACLU
Amy Goodman

Amy Goodman

By Amy Goodman
Armstrong Williams

Armstrong Williams

By Armstrong Williams
Austin Bay

Austin Bay

By Austin Bay
Ben Shapiro

Ben Shapiro

By Ben Shapiro
Betsy McCaughey

Betsy McCaughey

By Betsy McCaughey
Bill Press

Bill Press

By Bill Press
Bonnie Jean Feldkamp

Bonnie Jean Feldkamp

By Bonnie Jean Feldkamp
Cal Thomas

Cal Thomas

By Cal Thomas
Christine Flowers

Christine Flowers

By Christine Flowers
Clarence Page

Clarence Page

By Clarence Page
Danny Tyree

Danny Tyree

By Danny Tyree
David Harsanyi

David Harsanyi

By David Harsanyi
Debra Saunders

Debra Saunders

By Debra Saunders
Dennis Prager

Dennis Prager

By Dennis Prager
Dick Polman

Dick Polman

By Dick Polman
Erick Erickson

Erick Erickson

By Erick Erickson
Froma Harrop

Froma Harrop

By Froma Harrop
Jacob Sullum

Jacob Sullum

By Jacob Sullum
Jamie Stiehm

Jamie Stiehm

By Jamie Stiehm
Jeff Robbins

Jeff Robbins

By Jeff Robbins
Jessica Johnson

Jessica Johnson

By Jessica Johnson
Jim Hightower

Jim Hightower

By Jim Hightower
Joe Conason

Joe Conason

By Joe Conason
Joe Guzzardi

Joe Guzzardi

By Joe Guzzardi
John Micek

John Micek

By John Micek
John Stossel

John Stossel

By John Stossel
Josh Hammer

Josh Hammer

By Josh Hammer
Judge Andrew Napolitano

Judge Andrew Napolitano

By Judge Andrew P. Napolitano
Laura Hollis

Laura Hollis

By Laura Hollis
Marc Munroe Dion

Marc Munroe Dion

By Marc Munroe Dion
Michael Barone

Michael Barone

By Michael Barone
Michael Reagan

Michael Reagan

By Michael Reagan
Mona Charen

Mona Charen

By Mona Charen
Oliver North and David L. Goetsch

Oliver North and David L. Goetsch

By Oliver North and David L. Goetsch
R. Emmett Tyrrell

R. Emmett Tyrrell

By R. Emmett Tyrrell
Rachel Marsden

Rachel Marsden

By Rachel Marsden
Rich Lowry

Rich Lowry

By Rich Lowry
Robert B. Reich

Robert B. Reich

By Robert B. Reich
Ruben Navarrett Jr

Ruben Navarrett Jr

By Ruben Navarrett Jr.
Ruth Marcus

Ruth Marcus

By Ruth Marcus
S.E. Cupp

S.E. Cupp

By S.E. Cupp
Salena Zito

Salena Zito

By Salena Zito
Star Parker

Star Parker

By Star Parker
Stephen Moore

Stephen Moore

By Stephen Moore
Susan Estrich

Susan Estrich

By Susan Estrich
Ted Rall

Ted Rall

By Ted Rall
Terence P. Jeffrey

Terence P. Jeffrey

By Terence P. Jeffrey
Tim Graham

Tim Graham

By Tim Graham
Tom Purcell

Tom Purcell

By Tom Purcell
Veronique de Rugy

Veronique de Rugy

By Veronique de Rugy
Victor Joecks

Victor Joecks

By Victor Joecks
Wayne Allyn Root

Wayne Allyn Root

By Wayne Allyn Root

Comics

David Horsey Steve Benson John Deering Lisa Benson Tim Campbell Marshall Ramsey