Manchin's opposition may doom clean-power plan Biden backs

Ari Natter, Bloomberg News on

Published in Political News

WASHINGTON — Sen. Joe Manchin has told the White House and congressional leaders that he will not support including a key clean-power provision in the Democrats’ spending package, putting at risk a central element of the legislation designed to fight climate change, according to a person familiar with the matter.

A final decision about the fate of the program, which would pay utilities for using clean energy and penalize those that don’t, hasn’t been made, said the person, who asked not to be identified discussing non-public deliberations. But without the support of Manchin, who holds a swing vote on the package, it’s not likely to survive, the person said.

“Senator Manchin has clearly expressed his concerns about using taxpayer dollars to pay private companies to do things they’re already doing,” Sam Runyon, a spokesman for Manchin, a West Virginia Democrat, said. “He continues to support efforts to combat climate change while protecting American energy independence and ensuring our energy reliability.”

The program, known as the Clean Electricity Performance Program, has been a major priority for the White House and President Joe Biden’s goal of de-carbonizing the nation’s electric grid by 2035. He’s due to travel to Scotland for a United Nations conference starting Oct. 31 where he’ll seek to show U.S. leadership on fighting climate change.

“We don’t comment on the state of our negotiations with the wide array of senators offering views about the Build Back Better agenda,” said Vedant Patel, a White House spokesman. “The White House is laser focused on advancing the president’s climate goals and positioning the United States to meet its emission targets in a way that grows domestic industries and good jobs.”

West Virginia is a leading producer of coal, which once fueled most of the nation’s power plants but has lost out to natural gas and fast-growing renewable energy sources such as wind and solar. The senator’s opposition was previously reported by the New York Times.

The White House and Democratic congressional leaders are discussing how to scale back the social-spending measure to win the votes of Manchin and another holdout Senate Democrat, Arizona’s Kyrsten Sinema.

Manchin has said he wants a top line of no more than $1.5 trillion over 10 years for the legislation, which backers initially wanted to total $3.5 trillion. Biden has said he thinks a compromise might be found around $2 trillion.

Biden, speaking at the White House Friday evening, was asked what his message would be to Manchin and Sinema. “I’m about to deliver it,” he said. He declined to specify if that meant he’d speak to them later Friday.


“The Clean Electricity Performance Program is a central part of President Biden’s plan to fight the climate crisis,” said Sam Ricketts, co-founder of the environmental group Evergreen Action. “It’s the single most-effective proposal to cut climate pollution in the Build Back Better Act.”

Democrats have pointed to other climate programs in the sweeping legislative package as they seek to pass something Biden, who vowed to cuts U.S. emissions in half by the end of the decade, can take with him to the UN climate summit.

Among them are hundreds of billions in dollars in tax breaks for alternative energy and electric vehicles and a fee on methane emissions from oil and gas operations.

A plan by approved by the Senate Finance Committee that ties the value of tax credits for energy production to its carbon intensity would reduce emissions in the power sector by 73% in the next 10 years, according to the panel’s chairman.

“While I strongly support the Clean Energy Payment Program, it’s important to note that the overwhelming majority of emissions reductions come from the energy tax overhaul in our Clean Energy for America Act,” Senator Ron Wyden, an Oregon Democrat, said in a statement Saturday.

“The Clean Energy for America Act is the linchpin of our climate package, and I will continue working with my colleagues to get it across the finish line,” he said.

Other climate programs Senate Democrats have eyed for the package are the elimination of tax credits for fossil fuels and a tax on carbon-dioxide emissions that could be used to offset some of the cost of a sweeping social-spending bill.

While Manchin voted with members of his party on a messaging amendment earlier this year in support of such a tax, he has since made critical comments about the fee.

©2021 Bloomberg L.P. Visit bloomberg.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.