From the Right



The War On Gifted And Talented Programs


BYLINE: By Rich Lowry

Gifted students have to check their privilege and get over themselves.

It doesn't matter whether they are minorities. It doesn't matter whether they were brought to the United States as children. It doesn't matter how poor their families may be. It doesn't matter if they have inspiring personal stories. It doesn't matter how hard they work.

No, the very fact that they are getting accommodated in classrooms and programs that don't necessarily represent the demographic makeup of school districts at large means that they need to be brought down a notch.

If there were any doubt that "equity" is now the most destructive concept in American life, the war on gifted and talented programs all around the country, from California (on the verge of eliminating tracking in math through the 10th grade), to Seattle (which eliminated its honors program for middle school students), to suburban Philadelphia (where a district is curtailing tracking for middle school and high school students), removes all doubt.

New York City has been a major battleground for the anti-gifted agenda that runs under the banner of desegregation, as if the offense of the George Wallaces of the world is no longer blocking the schoolhouse door but teaching exceptionally talented students at an accelerated pace.


Mayor Bill de Blasio just moved to significantly crimp the city's gifted programs, disproportionately utilized by white and Asian American kids, in a sop to racialist bean-counters. As The New York Times notes, the mayor has been "criticized for not taking forceful action to fulfill his promise of tackling inequality in public schools."

Not that he hasn't tried. Earlier in his administration, he appointed a panel that recommended eliminating almost all the city's selective programs, alleging that they are "proxies for separating students who can and should have opportunities to learn together."

He attempted to ax the exclusive admissions exam for the city's top high schools, which the left hates for having the "wrong" demographics. The school's chancellor at the time, Richard Carranza, slammed "the narrative that any one ethnic group owns admission to these schools," i.e., in his perverted view, Asian American kids were unfairly achieving beyond their numbers.

Outraged parents defeated the plan. De Blasio then eliminated some admissions requirements at the city's selective middle and high schools. Now, he's re-engineering the city's approach to gifted students more broadly.


swipe to next page



Randy Enos Jack Ohman Dan Wasserman Pat Byrnes Joel Pett Bob Englehart