From the Right

/

Politics

Student Loan Forgiveness: A Payoff for the Woke

Michael Barone on

"A Bailout for Woke Higher Ed" reads the headline on the stringent analysis by the Wall Street Journal's Allysia Finley of the Biden student loan forgiveness program.

It's a program that's economically regressive, "even worse than you thought," with big bailouts for the most affluent, as economist Tyler Cowen points out.

It's wildly more expensive than advertised, according to Penn Wharton, with costs rising to the magnitude of $600 billion to $1 trillion, two to three times the expected price tag.

To understand why this policy is so rotten, go back to its origins. Many years ago, some policymakers noticed that the small minority of Americans who graduated from college earned more than the large majority who didn't. They deduced that if more people went to college, they'd earn more themselves and increase the gross domestic product. So let's loan them money for tuition and expenses.

But at some point, there are diminishing returns.

Not everyone has the talents and temperament to profit from college. When you get majorities entering higher education -- colleges and universities, or just community colleges -- many drop out, and some end up making less than if they'd skipped college and just gotten a job. Even worse, they end up owing more.

 

America seems to have reached that point some time ago. Graduates' unemployment rates and the (perhaps more wrenching) percentage living with parents rose from the 1990s to the last decade. Economists David Autor and Arindrajit Dube have found that college graduates' wages have fallen more since 2020 than those of college dropouts or high school graduates. Returns on college seem increasingly dismal -- negative, even -- for dropouts and marginal graduates and may be reducing rather than increasing total GDP.

The result is what economic historian Peter Turchin calls "the overproduction of elites," people with elite credentials but not necessarily superior abilities. Such overproduction, Turchin argues, has historically produced "socio-political instability," which he predicted in 2010 would be a feature of the 2010-20 decade. We've seen plenty of instability in politics, the economy and higher education, where students have been shunning humanities for more practical majors, and an oversupply of Ph.D.s has resulted in competition for fewer tenure track positions and more teaching by near-minimum-wage adjuncts.

So, where has all that government student loan money gone? Not to increased capacity: Even schools with huge endowments haven't increased enrollments.

Instead, colleges and universities have mopped up the money by raising tuition and charges for gold-plated dorms and gyms -- and for staff. From 2000 to 2020, tuitions increased 170%, more than twice the inflation rate, while prices of market-provided goods barely rose (cars, furniture, clothing) or sharply fell (cellphones, software).

...continued

swipe to next page
Copyright 2022 U.S. News and World Report. Distibuted by Creators Syndicate Inc.
 

 

Comics

Mike Luckovich Dana Summers Daryl Cagle Bill Day Bob Gorrell Chris Britt