From the Left

/

Politics

Orbán is offensive in the present tense, but he offends the past as well

Richard Cohen on

Donald Trump serves up a daily smorgasbord of offenses. He lies with almost every breath. He promulgates policy by inane tweet. He hires on a whim, fires out of pique and runs through the federal government spreading chaos and confusion as a fairy might spread pixie dust. He is his own Mount Rushmore of incompetence and vile behavior. He is the most un-American of American presidents.

Last week, Trump welcomed Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán to the White House. Any other American president would not have extended the invitation in the first place. It could have been avoided. Hungary is a landlocked country with not even 10 million people. It represents no balance of power, no major trading partner. Its best days are behind it, its glorious heroism in standing up to the Russians in 1956 is not even a memory to the current generation of historically blank Americans -- Trump, until recently, no doubt included.

Hungary's fame is now infamy. Under Orbán, it has lurched to the right -- not into mere populism, but into a sort of pre-fascism. Civil liberties and political rights have been curtailed. The judiciary is being brought to heel. The visage of philanthropist George Soros, made into the durable caricature of the Wandering Jew of old, was plastered around Hungary. "Don't let Soros have the last laugh," the posters said. The posters were of a single man. But the man, really, was a people.

"They do not fight directly, but by stealth," Orbán said in a speech last year. "They are not honorable, but unprincipled; they are not national, but international; they do not believe in work, but speculate with money; they have no homeland, but feel that the whole world is theirs. They are not generous, but vengeful, and always attack the heart -- especially if it is red, white and green [the colors of the Hungarian flag]."

The "they" of this rancid speech is no mystery. It is the same Jews that informed the anti-Semitic speeches of Adolf Hitler, and those of Hungary's own fascist party, the Arrow Cross Party. That Orbán could continue this foul heritage is something of a marvel. Hungary's Jews were nearly obliterated in the Holocaust -- more than 437,000 were sent to Auschwitz alone, an organizational feat pulled off by the diligent Adolf Eichmann. Orbán's scapegoats are ghostly memories.

Soros was a Hungarian Jew who survived the Nazi occupation and the pogroms organized by the homespun Arrow Cross, which filled the storied Danube with the bodies of its victims, shot at the river bank. And yet, Soros all-but returned to Hungary, aiding its incipient democracy movement, funding a university and making grants to individual Hungarians of promise. One of them was the young Viktor Orbán.

Trump took no notice of any of this in his photo-op remarks during Orbán's visit. "People have a lot of respect for this prime minister," Trump said. "He's a respected man. And I know he's a tough man, but he's a respected man. And he's done the right thing, according to many people, on immigration."

Actually, Orbán has done the wrong thing on immigration. He's called Syrian refugees "Muslim invaders," which is an odd thing to call bedraggled and hapless refugees mostly just passing through. According to a CNN poll, Hungary is the most anti-Semitic country in Europe. If it is not also the most anti-Muslim, Orbán must wonder where he went wrong.

 

Right-wing populism has reappeared in a Europe that has seen it before. Until very recently in Austria the far-right Freedom Party had taken over the Interior Ministry, often the first stop on the way to a dictatorship. Other countries are being threatened. You would expect an American president to defend democracy. Not this one, though.

Even by the standards of photo-op blather and even by the standards of Trump's own praise of strongmen like Vladimir Putin of Russia or Abdel-Fattah el-Sissi of Egypt, Trump's welcome of Orbán is in a class of its own. Orbán is not merely a "tough man" -- so were Hitler and Stalin -- but a smotherer of democracy and a demagogic bigot. His anti-Semitism has had an effect.

Viktor Orbán is offensive in the present tense, but he offends the past as well. He proceeds as if the Holocaust never happened -- as if Jews were never murdered for being Jewish, as if the Arrow Cross aid the Nazis in killing an additional 80,000 Jews. Orbán is an heir to that Arrow Cross. Trump is an heir to everyone who looked away.

========

Richard Cohen's email address is cohenr@washpost.com.

(c) 2019, Washington Post Writers Group

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus
 

Social Connections

Comics

A.F. Branco Steve Benson Mike Peters Mike Luckovich John Branch Marshall Ramsey