From the Left



George H.W. Bush's funeral was a powerful renunciation of Trump

Dana Milbank on

WASHINGTON -- George Herbert Walker Bush, before his death, said he wanted President Trump to attend his funeral, a generous gesture that forgave the cavalcade of insults that Trump has rained on the Bush family.

It was a final show of the sound judgment Bush exercised in life.

Trump's name was mentioned not once by the four eulogists at Washington National Cathedral on Wednesday. But their words were an implicit rebuke of everything Trump is. They spoke of what made Bush a great leader, which are the very traits that, by their absence, make Trump so woefully inadequate.

During his eulogy, Bush biographer Jon Meacham identified Bush's "thousand points of light" -- a phrase Trump has ridiculed -- as a "companion verse" to Abraham Lincoln's "better angels of our nature," because "Lincoln and Bush both called on us to choose the right over the convenient, to hope rather than to fear, and to heed not our worst impulses, but our best instincts."

And there, in the front pew, was Trump, who leads by stoking fear and confirming base impulses.

George W. Bush recalled of his father: "In victory, he shared credit. When he lost, he shouldered the blame." Bush invoked his dad's "unlikeliest" friendship with Bill Clinton as they went from opponents to "brothers from other mothers."

--Sponsored Video--

Trump, a few seats from former president Clinton, alternated between folding arms impassively across his chest and leaning forward uncomfortably. Could he comprehend the ideas of giving credit, accepting blame or forgiving?

Bush friend Alan Simpson, the former Wyoming senator, said the 41st president "never hated anyone" and loyalty "coursed through his blood," including a "loyalty to the institutions of government." This must be incomprehensible to Trump, who dispenses hatred in 280-character increments, demands loyalty but offers none in return and trashes the institutions of government for sport.

And the current president, though not given to self-reflection, could not have missed the rebuke delivered by another eulogist, former Canadian prime minister Brian Mulroney, who praised Bush for negotiating the North American Free Trade Agreement (which Trump has called the "worst trade deal in history"); for environmentalism (which Trump derides); and for international leadership (which Trump dismisses).

"When George Bush was president," Mulroney said, "every single head of government in the world knew that they were dealing with a gentleman, a genuine leader, one who was distinguished, resolute and brave."


swipe to next page


blog comments powered by Disqus

Social Connections


Andy Marlette Kirk Walters Lee Judge Steve Benson Jimmy Margulies Signe Wilkinson