From the Left



Jussie Smollett and the rush to judgment

By Clarence Page, Tribune Content Agency on

California Sen. Kamala Harris and New Jersey Sen. Cory Booker, both Democratic presidential hopefuls, called the attack "an attempted modern-day lynching."

New York Sen. Kirsten Gillibrand, a Democrat considering a run for president, tweeted: "This is a sickening and outrageous attack and horribly, it's the latest of too many hate crimes against LGBTQ people and people of color."

Freshman New York Democratic Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez tweeted that it was "a racist and homophobic attack" and "It is no one's job to water down or sugar-coat the rise of hate crimes."

Maybe not but, as any reputable police reporter will tell you, it pays to be cautious and make frequent use of qualifiers like "allegedly" and "reportedly" and "according to police" when passing on raw crime reports.

The reason for that became obvious this past weekend when unnamed law enforcement sources told the Chicago Tribune and other media that police are now investigating whether Smollett paid two Nigerian brothers who reportedly worked with him on "Empire" -- one of whom also was Smollett's personal trainer -- to stage the attack on him. Smollett has denied that charge but has continued putting off speaking further with police, who have said they have more questions for him.

Conservatives, like those who emailed me, have had a jolly good time mocking liberals who, as this story first broke, seemed eager to accept Smollett's alleged victimization, despite a shortage of corroborating evidence.

"Hey Hollywood and media types," tweeted Donald Trump Jr., the president's eldest son and, following daddy's footsteps, proud Twitter troll. "I've noticed a lot of you deleted your #JusticeForJussie tweets ... what's the matter, don't you want justice for him anymore??? #frauds."

Well, considering his role as a person of great interest to special counsel Robert Mueller's investigation of alleged Russian interference in our 2016 elections, Don Jr. probably should not be too cocky.


Yet, like his dad, he couldn't keep his thumbs off Twitter. The Advocate counted "no less than 35 tweets, retweets and references to Smollett on Trump Jr.'s Twitter in 48 hours" before the weekend.

There's no question that a lot of people have rushed to judgment about this story. Some even forgot those valuable little "allegedly" and "reportedly" disclaimers. Yet I find it amusing to see how often the same people who accused us media workers of rushing to judgment when Smollett was viewed as a victim suddenly began rushing to judgment themselves about his possible guilt, once the tables started to turn.

In the pursuit of justice, after all, it is important to remember that, throughout the weekend's flurry of news and gossip about the story, Smollett had not been charged officially with any wrongdoing.

Like anyone else in this country, he has the right to be presumed innocent until found guilty, even if it does turn out he committed a hate crime against himself.


(E-mail Clarence Page at




Bill Bramhall Ken Catalino David M. Hitch Jimmy Margulies Steve Kelley Mike Peters