Home & Leisure

Making a good thing better: These sloppy Joes will appeal to kids and adults alike

By America’s Test Kitchen, Tribune Content Agency on

It’s easy to understand why sloppy Joes are a beloved family favorite. The filling couldn’t be easier to make, and it goes from skillet to table in less than 30 minutes. But there’s also room for improvement — such as the often dry meat, too-sweet sauce and the filling that falls off the bun — that if perfected, would make it more appealing to kids and adults alike.

First, we tackled the meat. We skipped the traditional browning step and mixed 1/2 teaspoon baking soda and 1 tablespoon water into the beef before cooking. This raises the pH of the meat, resulting in beef that’s juicier and more tender. We also used this technique for the chopped onion in the filling. Just 1/8 teaspoon of baking soda altered the onion’s pH, causing it to rapidly break down so it nearly melted into the sauce.

Next, the sauce. Most sloppy Joe recipes call for lots of ketchup — 1/2 cup to 1 cup — which makes the sandwiches overly sweet. We dropped the ketchup to just 1/3 cup and balanced it out with generous amounts of two umami-rich ingredients: earthy tomato paste and Worcestershire sauce. This took the filling from cloying to savory-sweet.

The beef was moist and tender, and the multidimensional sauce was downright irresistible. Now we just needed to find a way to make the filling stay on the bun. Don’t get us wrong — we like the messy nature of this dish. But if everything tumbles out on the first bite, the sandwich is difficult to enjoy.

The key was using a potato masher to break up the beef in the pan into equal-size pieces and then stirring in a cornstarch slurry. In addition to acting as a thickener, the cornstarch held any separated fat in the sauce, creating a cohesive, silky texture.

We marveled at how these small changes markedly improved the filling. Now what went on the bun, (mostly) stayed on the bun. And good thing, since we didn’t want to lose any of the now-perfect filling and sauce.


Classic Sloppy Joes

Serves 4

2 tablespoons water, divided

1/2 teaspoon plus 1/8 teaspoon baking soda, divided


swipe to next page



Mike Du Jour Dinette Set Archie David Horsey RJ Matson Wee Pals