Life Advice


Health & Spirit

Sister-in-law prioritizes dog ownership over visits from her nephew

Carolyn Hax on

Important Note from ArcaMax Publishing: We regret to inform you that as of Nov. 1, the Washington Post syndication service will no longer license this column to ArcaMax. You may write The Post with your feedback here: or access the column online through the Washington Post paid service. After November 1, these columns will only be available to print publications.

Adapted from a recent online discussion.

Dear Carolyn:

My brother has always been a huge part of my 7-year-old son's life. My ex-husband works long hours and is not into sports or video games, which "Brian" loves, and my brother is a widower with a son a little older than Brian and has always been the one to take Brian to sporting events and play video games with him.

Brian really looked forward to sleepovers at his uncle's house and sees my nephew as a big brother. The problem is, my brother remarried and Brian is extremely allergic to her dog. He can't spend any time at their home, so Brian saw much less of them.

The dog died last month and I was thinking Brian could start going over as soon as they gave the house a thorough cleaning. Now I find out my sister-in-law is looking at getting another dog. When I asked my brother why, knowing Brian can never stay with them, he just shrugged and said his wife can't live without a dog. My sister-in-law always seemed to love my son but when I asked if she would consider getting another kind of pet, she flat-out refused.

I am trying not to resent her but it's clear she loves dogs more than my son and doesn't care how this will affect his relationship with his uncle and cousin. Is there any other way to look at this?

-- Resentful

"[S]he loves dogs more than my son" is not a productive use of your facts.

A dog is a way of life, and it's daily. To expect someone to change her daily way of life so your son can visit is a much bigger ask than you seem to realize.


swipe to next page


blog comments powered by Disqus

Social Connections


Agnes Ginger Meggs Nest Heads Breaking Cat News Aunty Acid Wallace The Brave