Life Advice


Health & Spirit

She wants a fairy-tale wedding. Should he put a (huge) ring on it?

Carolyn Hax on

Dear Carolyn:

My girlfriend of three years always badgered me about getting married before our four-year anniversary. At first the arbitrary deadline annoyed me, but after living together for two years and working through the death of her mother, I really am taking the thought seriously. I've even started to save up for a ring.

She's very particular about jewelry, and I've never bought her any before, so I opened up a conversation about engagement rings and she immediately became uncomfortable. A few days later she brought it back up and had talked to some of her friends who I suspect might have given her ideas for a ring beyond my means. When I attempted to temper her expectations she immediately lost patience with me and refused to discuss the matter any further.

When we started dating she'd always tell me she had a pretty elaborate picture of how her wedding would go down, and often showed me fantastic online videos of guys proposing while pulling off impossible stunts. I love my girlfriend, but I'm starting to wonder if I can ever live up to her fantasy, especially when talking about the future only crushes her dreams.

-- Confused

Does she love you ? Or just your willingness to squeeze yourself into the role she's imagined since she was a kid?


This isn't about your worthiness as a partner, to her or anyone else; she might like or even love who you really are if she stops thinking about herself long enough to see it.

It's strictly about the danger of such a single-minded focus on what a romance is supposed to look like and the attention it can afford her. How can a person see what's really there when her whole field of vision is occupied by expectations she built before she met you and apparently hasn't reflected on since?

The way it usually plays out, unfortunately, is that people use fixed expectations to build relationships that work for a while as role-playing before they inevitably collapse -- when, as the years pile up, reality refuses to be ignored.

It's also possible I'm overstating the role of expectations here, and your girlfriend really does see you and know you and love you. But that's not what you see. You see "badgered" and "annoyed" and "arbitrary" and "particular about jewelry" and "beyond my means" and "lost patience" and "refused to discuss" and "impossible stunts" and, mercifully, "I'm starting to wonder if I can ever live up to her fantasy."


swipe to next page


blog comments powered by Disqus

Social Connections


Master Strokes: Golf Tips Steve Breen Chip Bok Jeff Danziger Dennis the Menace Breaking Cat News