From the Left

/

Politics

A Vaxxing Dilemma

By Clarence Page, Tribune Content Agency on

Is support for childhood vaccinations a partisan issue? Polls indicate that it isn't, yet Republicans appear to be getting stung by this needle more than Democrats are.

The question has come up after Republican presidential hopefuls Chris Christie and Rand Paul said that parents should have a choice and not be required by law to immunize their children.

Paul, a senator and licensed ophthalmologist from Kentucky, went further in a CNBC interview. He expressed belief in a link between vaccines and "profound mental disorders," even though the only study that claimed such a link was later debunked.

Christie, the New Jersey governor who famously and unnecessarily confined a nurse on the suspicion that she might have Ebola, clarified his immunization stance a bit after a backlash. Scientific support for vaccination was "pretty indisputable," he said.

President Obama and other leading presidential hopefuls in both parties also urged parents to get their kids vaccinated, while mostly tiptoeing around the question of whether the vaccine should be required.

Among Democrats, Hillary Clinton, still holding the Democratic field pretty much to herself, tweeted confidence: "The science is clear: The earth is round, the sky is blue, and #vaccineswork." President Obama on NBC's "Today" show similarly urged parents to get their kids vaccinated.

 

As parents who refuse to vaccinate their kids, often called "anti-vaxxers," receive widespread blame for a resurgence of measles in this country, a partisan dispute has arisen over which anti-vaxxers to blame: upper-income, organic-food-buying liberals or libertarian, anti-government, tea party conservatives?

After all, conservatives have been quick to point out, the new measles epidemic originated in politically blue California, one of the states that offers a variety of voluntary "personal belief" exemptions to parents who want to opt-out of mandatory vaccine requirements.

Red-state Mississippi, by comparison, offers no religious exemption for vaccines, has the highest compliance rate in the country and hasn't had a reported measles case in two decades, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Liberals respond that, while anti-vaxxers certainly exist on the left -- and some even fit the stereotypes about yuppie organic food shoppers -- they have essentially no political influence as a group. Since the Bill Clinton era, the Democratic Party has tried to corral its fringe elements, while Republicans have struggled between their right wing and their far-right wing.

...continued

swipe to next page

(c) 2015 CLARENCE PAGE DISTRIBUTED BY TRIBUNE MEDIA SERVICES, INC.

 

 

Comics

Tom Stiglich Kevin Siers Clay Bennett Scott Stantis Steve Benson Ed Wexler