On “Breaking Amish,” Jeremiah and Abe ventured to a strip club for the first time. Abe felt uncomfortable and bailed, but Jeremiah stayed behind. “He wouldn’t do it, so I went in and I enjoyed it,” Jeremiah said. “I definitely enjoyed it. Had two girls dancing all over me. Had a lot of fun. Only bad thing is I walked out with a boner and nothing else!” Abe went back to their hotel room and told Rebecca he didn’t want to disrespect her by getting a lap dance.